• Loading stock data...
Friday, July 11, 2025

The A’s Mess Should Make MLB Do Some Soul Searching, But It Won’t

There is something wrong with a league that allows this to happen.

MLB commissioner Rob Manfred looks on during the presentation of the Allan H. Selling Award for philanthropic excellence during the 2022 MLB Winter Meetings at Manchester Grand Hyatt.
Orlando Ramirez-USA TODAY Sports

Whenever the Oakland A’s stadium situation approaches a resolution, the road curves, and the team returns to the maze. Various paths lead to Las Vegas, Oakland, or alternate possibilities, namely, selling the team. But in the labyrinthine twists and tangles of all of this, a broader truth has emerged: There is something systemically wrong with a league that allows this to happen.

Major League Baseball appears from a distance to be an organization devoted to the long-term health of professional baseball in North America. Still, certain moments reveal that this is not strictly true. MLB is first and foremost concerned with appeasing its 30 ownership groups — a goal that largely, but not entirely, overlaps with promoting the sport’s long-term health.

The last few years have seen a handful of moments in which MLB has acted against the sport’s long-term health in service of their owners’ pocketbooks.

A minor league baseball game

Minor League Players to Get Big Salary Bump in Historic CBA

MiLB players are approaching their first ever collective bargaining agreement.
March 30, 2023

One such example is the yearslong effort to suppress minor league player salaries, including MLB’s successful lobbying for an exemption from minimum wage laws. (The tide turned on that issue earlier this year with minor leaguers joining the MLBPA and signing a collective bargaining agreement. That brought many changes, including raising single-A salaries from $11,000 to $26,200.) The 99-day lockout before the 2022 season, making the season itself into a hostage in labor negotiations, was another.

Losing by Design

And now we have the A’s and their owner John Fisher, who have chosen to have a non-competitive team. The A’s are on pace for the worst record in modern baseball history, not because of injuries and misjudgments, but because they chose to trade all their best players and received very little in return. 

Following the 2021 season, the A’s were coming off four consecutive winning seasons, including three playoff appearances. Their core players, namely Matt Chapman, Matt Olson, and Sean Murphy were in their primes and under team control for multiple seasons.

By Fangraphs’ Wins Above Replacement stat, four of MLB’s dozen most valuable hitters were A’s as recently as 2020.

Another team would have attempted to sign some of those players to long-term deals and filled gaps with free agents. But the A’s commitment to frugality far exceeds their attempts to win.

A Public Failure

Oakland’s only focus as an organization, the only thing that draws any investment of time and resources, is extracting public money for their next venue. 

Their roster is the cheapest in MLB by a healthy margin, their stadium was famously home to feral cats last year and possums this year, and after getting deep into talks with the city on a community benefits program, they informed officials that they wouldn’t be paying for it. 

To be fair, even their attempts at public money seem hastily slapped together, with renderings that don’t necessarily fit on the nine acres allotted to them by Bally’s and projections that strain credulity, including that 405,000 people would travel to Las Vegas every year to see them who otherwise would not have come, and that the team would create 10,000 permanent jobs (currently 670 people say they are employed by the team on LinkedIn).

The A's have shared renderings of its proposed Las Vegas stadium.
A rendering of the Oakland A’s proposed Las Vegas stadium.

They haven’t even been able to stick to their promises in their brief time as a team ostensibly committed to the move: In April, they claimed to have signed a “binding agreement” to purchase land owned by Red Rock Resorts, only to drop that deal the following month for the Bally’s-managed Tropicana site. Reports later revealed that they toured a third site after agreeing to move forward with the Tropicana site.

Many A’s fans believe Fisher’s gutting the roster while raising ticket prices is a calculated move to drive away fans to strengthen the premise that the team has no future in Oakland. 

The Blame Game

Fisher is a problem, but it’s the league that enables him. MLB commissioner Rob Manfred works for MLB owners. They pay him, and they can fire him. When a non-competitive team is put on the field, Manfred has decided it is in his best interest to support that owner. 

When asked about the A’s move, he has only blamed the city of Oakland, not Fisher, for their inability to reach a deal, despite the city raising $375 million for infrastructure surrounding a ballpark development, conducting and passing an environmental impact report, changing the designation of Howard Terminal to allow for development there, and agreeing to the A’s ask that neither side speaks to the media.

The A's have shared renderings of its proposed Las Vegas stadium.

Nevada Senators Split on A’s Stadium Bill

Nevada senators were split on funding a stadium for the Oakland A’s.
June 8, 2023

The week the A’s announced that they purchased land in Las Vegas, the team and Oakland officials, including the mayor, were scheduled to have a negotiation summit to hammer out many details of an agreement.

Manfred’s calculation in supporting Fisher unequivocally is presumably that it would establish a precedent of expansion instead of one in which owners could be cajoled into spending more or even selling their team.

But for the sport’s health, MLB owners ought to be put in a position that treats their roles as a privilege that can be taken away. Otherwise, we are simply left to hope that the sports’ 30 owners care about the fans — and to suffer the consequences when they don’t.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Jeff Kaplan

Letting PE Invest in Family-Owned Teams Is a ‘Watershed’

Liquidity gives owners greater flexibility to manage salary cap.

All-Star Game Returns to Atlanta With Big Plans After 2021 Exit

The league’s jewel event is set to be a global showcase for The Battery.
Rimouski, QC - JUNE 1: Final Game of the 2025 Memorial Cup between the Medicine Hats Tigers and the London Knights on June 1, 2025, at the Colisée Financière Sun Life in Rimouski, Qc.

CHL Is Facing a ‘Pandora’s Box’ of Questions Amid NCAA Talent Departure

As players defect to college, the Canadian Hockey League won’t cede ground.
Bruce Meyer and Tony Clark of the MLBPA

MLB, Players’ Union Spar Over Salary Cap As Labor Fight Looms

The MLB Players Association’s No. 2 executive outlines what he sees owners doing.

Featured Today

Jun 28, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA; Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (29) bats during the game between the Texas Rangers and the Seattle Mariners at Globe Life Field.

The Torpedo Bat Business Is Still Going Strong: ‘Here to Stay’

Demand for the oddly shaped bats has stayed strong across the sport.
July 6, 2025

American Celebs Want to Be Sports Owners. Soccer Is Where They Start

As U.S. team prices climb, investors set their sights abroad.
July 5, 2025

Baseball’s Celebrity Row: Behind MLB’s First-Pitch Ritual

Often planned, sometimes spontaneous, the ritual throw is baseball’s celebrity row.
July 4, 2025

3,000 Hot Dogs, $20K in Prizes: Behind the Nathan’s Eating Contest

Nathan’s serves up thousands of hot dogs and $20,000 in prize money.
Apr 6, 2024; Miami, Florida, USA; The LIV Golf logo is on display along the 10th hole during the second round of LIV Golf Miami golf tournament at Trump National Doral.

LIV Golf’s New Leadership Reapplies for World Ranking Points

The league’s first attempt was denied in 2023.
Feb 5, 2025; New Orleans, LA, USA; NFLPA executive director Lloyd Howell during the NFLPA press conference at the Super Bowl LIX media center at the Ernest N. Morial Convention Center.
July 10, 2025

NFLPA Head Has Side Hustle With PE Firm That Can Invest in..

The NFLPA’s executive director is embroiled in multiple controversies.
Stephen Curry celebrates after sinking the winning putt during the final round of the American Century Celebrity Championship golf tournament at Edgewood Tahoe Golf Course in Stateline, Nev., Sunday, July 16, 2023.
July 10, 2025

Golf’s Hottest Celebrity Tournament Keeps Getting More Exclusive

The American Century Championship tees off at Lake Tahoe on Friday.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
July 10, 2025

Murphy: Club WC Snags Won’t Derail Biggest Event ‘in Human History’

New Jersey’s MetLife Stadium is the concluding site of both FIFA events.
Crystal Palace FC
July 10, 2025

Crystal Palace’s Europa League Spot in Limbo After Lyon Wins Appeal

The ruling on Olympique Lyonnais was overturned this week on appeal.
July 9, 2025

U.K. Appoints New Soccer Regulator, EPL Matches Stay Behind Paywall

Men’s soccer in England will receive new levels of oversight.
July 9, 2025

NFL’s Alternate Uniforms Fuel Big Business—and Lots of Nostalgia

The Commanders kick off a run of new NFL helmets and uniforms.