• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, December 11, 2024
The 2024 Best Employers in Sports Award winners have been announced! See the full list of winners

State Legislators Argue Existing Laws Conflict With House v. NCAA Settlement Terms

A group of lawmakers say the proposed cap on revenue-sharing and NIL clearinghouse violate multiple existing state laws.

Ken Ruinard/Imagn Images

The House v. NCAA settlement proposal faces opposition from multiple state lawmakers.

On Thursday, a group of state legislators released a joint statement saying their state laws directly conflict with the terms of the settlement. The lawmakers made the statement in conjunction with the National College Players Association, the college athlete advocacy organization that has worked with state lawmakers on name, image, and likeness (NIL) legislation for several years.

“We worked hard to adopt NIL laws specifically to end the NCAA and conferences’ unjust NIL restrictions imposed on college athletes in our states. Our state NIL laws passed with overwhelming bipartisan support,” State Sen. Nancy Skinner (D., Calif.), Sen. Megan Hunt (I., Neb.), State Sen. James Manning Jr. (D., Ore.), and State Steven Bradford (D., Calif.) said. “Terms in the preliminary settlement in House v. NCAA attempt to allow the NCAA and conferences to restrict our college athletes’ freedom.” 

The settlement, which could receive the final stamp of approval from a judge in April, allows for the NCAA and former Power 5 conferences to pay $2.8 billion in damages to athletes who couldn’t receive NIL earnings before 2021. It also creates a template for revenue-sharing, allowing schools to share up to a certain amount with players in their athletic department every year. 

But it also places new restrictions on NIL. It would allow a third party to run a “clearinghouse” with the ability to block any NIL deals offered by boosters or collectives offering “fair-market value” for NIL activities, like endorsements or autograph signings. The goal is to prevent deals they see as “pay-for-play.” 

The state lawmakers said that the cap on revenue-sharing as well as the NIL clearinghouse violate multiple state laws. They also note that, because the states themselves aren’t parties to the lawsuit, they’re not bound to its terms.

They are urging schools to consider state laws when putting together their future compensation strategies. They also said they are sending letters to universities that “clarify that, even if this settlement is granted final approval, our universities, conferences, and the NCAA are prohibited from imposing such NIL restrictions on athletes and universities in our state.”

At least 17 states—including Michigan, California, New York, and Ohio—prohibit “restrictions on athletes’ freedoms to earn NIL compensation from collectives as described in the settlement,” according to NCPA executive director Ramogi Huma. Four states also already have laws that let schools pay players already.

The NCAA is working to stop this dynamic with a lobbying campaign to get Congress to codify the terms of the settlement, and therefore override these state laws. The governing body also hopes to insert a provision stating athletes cannot be classified as employees.

Huma, meanwhile, tells Front Office Sports he is working with lawmakers to pass similar state laws. But he notes, “Unless the NCAA can enforce NIL restrictions on all universities, it won’t enforce NIL restrictions on any universities. The universities in the other states aren’t going to be handcuffed while universities in other states are free. We’ve seen this dynamic since July 2021. Even states with no NIL laws had athletes engaging in NIL activities.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Nov 3, 2024; Harrison, New Jersey, USA; New York Red Bulls midfielder Lewis Morgan (9) heads a ball during the first half against the Columbus Crew in a 2024 MLS Cup Playoffs Round One match at Red Bull Arena.

MLS Team to Play in ‘Sports Illustrated Stadium’ in $100M Naming Deal

It’s a partnership with a sister ticketing platform company, not the magazine.
Oct 20, 2024; East Rutherford, New Jersey, USA; Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie pre game against the New York Giants at MetLife Stadium.

Bills, Eagles, Dolphins Approve Adding New Minority Owners

Vince Carter and Tracy McGrady join the list of Bills owners.
FIFA

Saudis Awarded 2034 World Cup in Uncontested Vote

Saudi Arabia was the only option after Australia decided not to bid.

Featured Today

Nov 2, 2024; Denver, Colorado, USA; Detailed view of a Wilson NBA basketball held by a referee during the second half between the Utah Jazz against the Denver Nuggets at Ball Arena

‘Obvious Weak Point’: Refs Remain an NBA Gambling Concern

A season after Jontay Porter, the biggest risk may not be players.
Nov 2, 2024; Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA; Michigan Wolverines cheerleader runs with a flag before the game against the Oregon Ducks at Michigan Stadium.
opinion
December 7, 2024

College Football’s Billionaire Backer Era Begins

Is this the new normal in CFB recruiting?
LA Galaxy forward Dejan Joveljic (9) celebrates with midfielder Riqui Puig (10) after scoring a goal against Seattle Sounders FC in the second half in the 2024 MLS Cup Western Conference Final match at Dignity Health Sports Park
December 6, 2024

With or Without Messi, Major League Soccer Is Barreling Into the Future

After the Cup final, the league looks to accelerate its growth.
Dec 18, 2022; Lusail, Qatar; FIFA president Gianni Infantino claps during the awards ceremony after the 2022 World Cup final between Argentina and France at Lusail Stadium.
December 2, 2024

FIFA Wants More Matches. Resistance Is Growing Inside the Global Soccer World

Resentment and frustration over expanded schedules is nearing a breaking point.

Mountain West Adds UC Davis, Wants Northern Illinois

The Aggies’ football team will stay in the FCS.
December 10, 2024

Transfer Portal Chaos: Record Moves, Star QBs, and NIL Deals Reshape CFB

There has been unprecedented portal activity this year.
Notre Dame
December 11, 2024

College Football Playoff on Campuses Sends Ticket, Travel Prices Soaring

Postseason games are coming to South Bend, State College, Austin, and Columbus.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
Oct 22, 2024; Kansas City, MO, USA; TCU Horned Frogs center Sedona Prince (13) talks to media during Big 12 Women’s Basketball Media Day at T-Mobile Center.
December 10, 2024

Athletes in Landmark House Case Ask for College Players’ Association

Plaintiffs in the House v. NCAA case want more than just revenue-sharing.
December 9, 2024

College Football Playoff Teams Paid $27M for Non-Conference Schedules

Texas led the way with three games that cost $4.9 million.
December 9, 2024

CFP Era Redefines Bowl Season: Tradition Meets Transformation

The 12-team College Football Playoff is changing Bowl Season.
December 8, 2024

ESPN, ABC To Simulcast First Non-NBC Notre Dame Home Game Since 1990

The Fighting Irish will play the first game of the College Football Playoff.