• Loading stock data...
Thursday, June 19, 2025

South Dakota AG Challenges House v. NCAA Settlement Proposal

  • The attorney general and Board of Regents say the settlement is unfair for non-power conference schools and female athletes.
  • The complaint is “a step beyond an objection.”
Samantha Laurey / Argus Leader / USA TODAY NETWORK

Less than a week after a federal judge told attorneys to “go back to the drawing board” on the House v. NCAA settlement, the proposal has been hit with an objection from a state attorney general.

On Tuesday, South Dakota attorney general Marty Jackley filed a lawsuit against the NCAA over the financial structure of the settlement, which it says are unfair to non-power conference schools and female athletes. The complaint, filed in Brookings County Circuit Court, was joined by the South Dakota Board of Regents representing both South Dakota State University and the University of South Dakota. 

“I am disappointed that our South Dakota athletes and universities are paying the price for a settlement that did not involve any of our conduct,” Jackley said in a statement. “This settlement unlawfully and blatantly discriminates against female student-athletes by limiting them to less than 10 percent of the proceeds.”

In July, the NCAA and Power 5 conferences filed a proposal to settle House v. NCAA as well as two other antitrust lawsuits. The settlement contains two components: $2.8 billion in back-pay for athletes who couldn’t participate in NIL (name, image, and likeness) before 2021 and a future revenue-sharing agreement. Just last week, Northern District of California Judge Claudia Wilken did not grant preliminary approval to the settlement, mostly because of issues related to rules restricting NIL collective deals. The parties now have three weeks to determine whether they can still settle.

In the meantime, however, South Dakota’s attorney general—and the two universities in the state—argues in court documents that the settlement unfairly burdens non-power conference schools financially, even though they have no participation and had no say in the proposal. The NCAA’s portion of the damages will partially be paid by reductions to annual distributions to all Division I conferences—a reality that conferences originally decried, but have since decided to go along with, as Front Office Sports previously reported. The 13-page complaint also said the settlement finances are presented “in a manner that treats male and female athletes differently.” 

Part of the settlement approval process includes formal objections. So far, three groups of athletes have filed official grievances, though one has since been withdrawn. Houston Christian University, a D-I FCS school in the Southland Conference also filed an objection in June with similar gripes to the South Dakota contingent, though Judge Wilken declined to consider it mostly because Houston Christian wasn’t a party to the lawsuit.

“It’s a step beyond an objection to the House settlement,” Boise State sports law professor Sam Ehrlich tells FOS.As we saw with Houston Christian, there’s no way to object within the confines of that approval process, so this seems like a backhanded way to object to the disbursement mechanism in the House settlement. It probably doesn’t disturb the settlement itself [to the extent it’s still going to be a thing], but it could throw a major wrench in the way the NCAA wants to pay for it.”

The NCAA did not immediately respond to an emailed request for comment.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Jun 13, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Indiana Pacers guard Tyrese Haliburton (0) drives to the hoop past Oklahoma City Thunder forward Jalen Williams (8), guard Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (2) and forward Chet Holmgren (7) during the third quarter of game four of the 2025 NBA Finals at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.

Pacers, Fever Overwhelmed by Demand for Merch

“We have people waiting to get in the store at 10 in the morning.”
LeBron
breaking

Buss Family Selling Lakers to Mark Walter in Record-Smashing $10 Billion Deal

The Buss family has owned the Lakers since the 1970s.
John Fisher

A’s Owner John Fisher Eyes MLS Exit Ahead of Billion-Dollar Vegas Project

The Earthquakes owner said he had hired a bank for a sale.
Cheerleaders lead more than 1,700 Olentangy Berlin High School students during an Aug. 19 pep rally at the school as they celebrate being named America's "Most Spirited High School" by Varsity Brands.

Embattled Cheerleading Giant Launches First-Ever Pro Cheer League

PE-backed Varsity is launching a new league amid antitrust fallout.

Featured Today

Dec 5, 2024; Miami, FL, USA; FIFA president Gianni Infantino presents the FIFA Club World Cup trophy during the Club Word Cup draw at Telemundo Studios.

Revamped Club World Cup Is FIFA’s Billion-Dollar Gamble

The revamped soccer event debuts amid controversy.
Jun 10, 2025; Nashville, Tennessee, USA; United States head coach Mauricio Pochettino stands during the anthem against the Switzerland during the first at Geodis Park
June 14, 2025

Gold Cup Is Complicated for USMNT—but U.S. Soccer Has Its Eyes on..

Uncertain tournament success isn’t fazing forward-looking U.S. soccer.
Jan 24, 2017; Davidson, NC, USA; The Davidson Wildcats student section cheers during the first half against the Duquesne Dukes at McKillop Court at John M. Belk Arena. Davidson defeated Duquesne 74-60.
June 6, 2025

Every College Wants a Flashy Basketball GM Hire Right Now

The role is more important than ever, and the definition is ever-evolving.
August 31, 2024; Columbus, Ohio, USA; The Goodyear blimp flies over Ohio Stadium during the first half of Saturday’s NCAA Division I football game between the Akron Zips and the Ohio State Buckeyes.
June 6, 2025

Why the Goodyear Blimp Is at Every Major Sports Event

The airship wasn’t built to cover sports. Now it’s a regular presence.
Jun 16, 2025; Omaha, Neb, USA; Arkansas Razorbacks starting pitcher Gage Wood (14) celebrates completing a no hitter against the Murray State Racers at Charles Schwab Field.

College World Series Enters Cinderella Era

A series of upsets gives the fast-growing event a new look this year.
Texas' Sam Hurley watches the announcement of the competitors in the high jump at the 2023 NCAA outdoor track and field championships, June 9, 2023 at Mike A. Myers Stadium in Austin, Texas.
June 16, 2025

Revenue-Sharing Model Could Boost Programs in Football’s Shadow

“We’re not getting paid the millions of dollars that football is.”
Jun 14, 2025; Omaha, Neb, USA; LSU Tigers starting pitcher Kade Anderson (32) pitches against the Arkansas Razorbacks during the seventh inning at Charles Schwab Field.
June 16, 2025

How College Athlete Buyouts Could Work in the Revenue-Sharing Era

The buyouts could put both players and schools at a disadvantage.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Ted Leonsis unpacks basketball’s global rise, media rights, and portfolio ownership.
UT
June 12, 2025

Zakai Zeigler Denied Injunction for Fifth Year at Tennessee

The former Tennessee guard sued the NCAA over potential lost NIL earnings.
North Dakota Fighting Hawks guard Zach Kraft (1) shoots the ball on Friday, March 7, 2025, at Denny Sanford Premier Center in Sioux Falls, S.D.
June 12, 2025

House v. NCAA Settlement Is Here. Non-Power Conference Schools Still Have Questions

D-I administrators still have questions they haven’t gotten answered.
Mar 7, 2025; Greenville, SC, USA; Vanderbilt Commodores guard Leilani Kapinus (5) looks to pass against the South Carolina Gamecocks during the second half at Bon Secours Wellness Arena.
June 11, 2025

Group of Women Athletes Files Appeal of House v. NCAA Settlement Approval

It’s the first appeal of the landmark settlement, which was approved Friday.
Ohio State
June 10, 2025

Men’s College Basketball Adds Coach’s Challenge, but No Quarters—Yet

The NBA adopted the challenge rule before the 2019–20 season.