• Loading stock data...
Sunday, May 4, 2025

Soto Contract Echoes 2000 A-Rod Deal. Could Similar Fallout Follow?

The eye-popping numbers surrounding Juan Soto’s historic contract with the Mets are certainly new, but many of the underlying issues surrounding the deal are not. 

Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Baseball history doesn’t necessarily repeat, but it certainly rhymes, and the record-breaking $765 million free-agent contract for Juan Soto is poised to create massive fallout across the sport—just as a similarly historic deal for Alex Rodriguez did more than a generation ago.

In late 2000, Rodriguez signed a 10-year, $252 million deal with the Rangers, with the then-unprecedented deal being completed at the same MLB winter meetings hotel in Dallas and with the same agent, Scott Boras, as Soto’s new deal with the Mets. 

The Rodriguez deal was the highlight of a frenetic set of winter meetings that year with nearly $800 million in total player guarantees made in just a few days. The fallout from the financial largess, however, was often ugly—particularly in Texas. With Rodriguez, the Rangers suffered three straight losing seasons, as they were unable to build fully around the star shortstop, before trading him to the Yankees in early 2004, while he also later admitted to using performance-enhancing drugs during this period. By 2010, the entire Rangers franchise was sold in bankruptcy court. 

MLB, meanwhile, suffered both internal and external strife as a result of the Rodriguez deal. The league went through a bruising round of labor negotiations in 2002 with the MLB Players Association, narrowly averting a work stoppage with a last-minute agreement that, among other measures, reinstated the league’s luxury tax. Many small-market team owners decried the Rodriguez deal and the growing economic disparity in the sport, and after experimenting with various formulas, MLB in 2002 also introduced a straight-pool revenue-sharing system in which each team contributed 34% of its local revenue to the pool.

Many of the reforms ultimately were helpful, though, as MLB is now enjoying unrivaled competitive parity in major U.S. pro sports with no team winning a repeat World Series title since 2000. 

Back to the Future

The Soto deal threatens to bring many of those same conflicts back to the surface. Already, the league went through a 99-day lockout before reaching the 2022 labor deal with the players, and many of the sport’s large-scale economic issues are still decidedly unsettled—particularly as the local media industry continues to experience major disruption

The current collective bargaining agreement with the players expires after the 2026 season. Already, expectations have been heavy for another complex and potentially combative round of talks—particularly as the sport’s revenue flow, though growing in the aggregate to more than $11 billion annually, is changing at an accelerating pace. 

The 15-year term of the Soto deal with the Mets, also establishing a league record for its duration, will theoretically cover multiple contract periods with the MLB Players Association, a new set of national TV deals following the current ones expiring in 2028, and perhaps, an eventual reformation of that now-challenged local media landscape. 

The Mets, meanwhile, could still end up with a smaller 2025 payroll than in 2024, even with the historic addition of Soto. The team currently has about $249 million in salary commitments for next year. Even with numerous roster decisions unresolved, that figure is nearly $100 million less than the team’s spending this year, thanks to numerous obligations newly coming off its books, including traded pitchers Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer and free agents such as first baseman Pete Alonso and pitcher Luis Severino, who recently signed with the A’s

There are still some other notable commitments in place for the Mets, however, including the restructured deferral payments for the long-retired Bobby Bonilla that will continue until 2035—just four years before the end of Soto’s deal.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Front Office Sports
exclusive

Jayson Werth: Winning Belmont Stakes ‘Comparable’ Emotions to World Series

Werth spoke to FOS at Churchill Downs about the race day high.

TGL Team Owner Marc Lasry: TV Ratings Peak Was 4X Better Than..

Lasry said TGL would have been happy with 250,000 viewers per match.
Fubo-TV

Fubo Loses Subscribers; Focused on Disney Deal Despite Antitrust Probe

The streaming company plans to debut its planned sports bundle this fall.

Mets, Dodgers, Pitch Clock Push MLB to Best April Attendance Since 2017

The league eyes a third straight boost at the gates this season.

Featured Today

Apr 12, 2025; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; MLB umpire Ron Kulpa (46) calls a third strike during a game between the Cleveland Guardians and the Kansas City Royals at Progressive Field

Pro Refs Get Offered Free Lasik for Better Calls. Some Took It

Some pro officials have sprung for the offer for free corrective surgery.
Mint juelps
May 3, 2025

Inside the 120,000-Cup Mint Julep Frenzy of Kentucky Derby Weekend

The official cocktail at Churchill Downs costs $22—or $5,000.
May 1, 2025

How Larry Collmus Became the Longest-Running Kentucky Derby Caller

Collmus will call his 15th straight Derby on NBC.
Apr 25, 2025; Los Angeles, California, USA; Pittsburgh Pirates starting pitcher Paul Skenes (30) pitches during the first inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium
April 30, 2025

The Pirates Are Struggling, But Paul Skenes Fever Is Still Spreading

The 22-year-old pitcher is (finally) giving Pittsburgh something to cheer for.

Sovereignty Wins Kentucky Derby, $3.1M Purse

The total purse was raised to $5 million last year.
May 1, 2025

Liberty Media Faces Rising Speculation Over Potential F1 Sale

Pending sale rumors persist around the motorsports property.
Jun 23, 2024; Chicago, Illinois, USA; Chicago Sky forward Angel Reese (5) passes the ball against Indiana Fever forward NaLyssa Smith (1) during the second half of a basketball game at Wintrust Arena.
May 2, 2025

WNBA Takes Its Preseason College Series to a New Level

Multiple preseason WNBA games will be broadcast nationally.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Portfolio Players is our bi-weekly spotlight on the athletes and investors reshaping the business of sports. This week, venture capitalist Kai Cunningham unpacks why athletes land top deals and how the usual investing rules don’t always apply.
Jul 16, 2024; Los Angeles, California, USA; Seattle Storm forward Nneka Ogwumike (3) shoots the ball against LA Sparks forward Dearica Hamby (5) and LA Sparks forward Rickea Jackson (2) in the second half at Crypto.com Arena.
May 1, 2025

‘We’ve Been Aggressive’: WNBPA Director on CBA Negotiations

Priorities include improved salaries and more accessible maternity benefits.
April 30, 2025

NHL Coaching Carousel Spins Fast, Even for Highest-Paid

Eight teams are currently looking for new head coaches.
April 30, 2025

Kentucky Derby Arrives With $920M Churchill Downs Expansion Stalled

The iconic venue had planned a $920 million renovation project.
April 30, 2025

Trump, U.K. Discussing Turnberry Open Championship: Reports

The R&A is open to taking the major championship back to the course.