• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 9, 2025

NCAA Constitutional Convention: Real Reform or Legal Cover?

  • The NCAA claims the Constitutional Convention is aimed at major reform, but it’s also trying to evade future legal scrutiny.
  • The constitution draft would implement some changes, but continues to bait the courts with language that could spark or bolster lawsuits.
Photo: CHARLIE NYE/USA TODAY/Design: Alex Brooks

Today, the NCAA membership is meeting during a virtual convention to discuss a draft of an entirely new constitution, released last week. 

When the NCAA announced the convention this summer, it claimed it wanted to “rethink” college sports and modernize. But it’s also an attempt to make changes that would protect it from further legal scrutiny in the wake of the Alston decision.

The biggest change would be giving more power to divisions, conferences, and schools. But the NCAA almost can’t seem to give up on core principles, like amateurism, that the law and the public have questioned.

“How much does the NCAA want to go up against the courts? How much do they want to tempt fate in this regard?” Boise State law professor Sam Ehrlich told FOS. “Based on the draft, it seems like they’re very willing to do so.”

Holding on to Amateurism

By the second page of the draft, the NCAA already appears to be baiting a lawsuit.

The principle of amateurism has guided the NCAA’s business model for decades. The concept, which prohibits pay for play, was listed second in the draft’s principles only behind “the primacy of the academic experience.” 

Athletes “may not be compensated by a member institution for participating in a sport,” the draft said.

It’s a bold move for the NCAA to put amateurism in writing because of the Alston decision, which found not only that education-related restrictions violated antitrust law, but also that other compensation limits could be illegal, too. 

“It’s like playing chicken with the courts,” Ehrlich said. 

The text might not be an antitrust violation in itself, Kennyhertz Perry sports attorney Mit Winter told FOS. But in future lawsuits, “this line would be great evidence for the plaintiffs to point to.” 

Keeping ‘Student-Athlete’ Alive

The NCAA is putting an additional target on its back — in this case with the National Labor Relations Board — by continuing to use the phrase “student-athlete,” another tenet of amateurism.

The NCAA originally created the phrase to avoid giving athletes workers’ compensation benefits — classifying them as amateurs, not employees. 

But in September, NLRB general counsel Jennifer Abruzzo released a memo saying that if a complaint is lodged against the NCAA, she’ll say “student-athlete” misclassifies some athletes who could be considered employees. A complaint was filed just last week, Bloomberg reported

In the constitution draft, however, the athletes themselves insisted on using the phrase, according to Sportico.

It’s possible they have created their own associations with the label, Ehrlich said, or even agree with an “education-first model…especially outside of the revenue sports.” 

But from a legal perspective, athletes might not understand the “potential significance of continuing to use that term,” Winter said.

Creating an NIL Loophole

The NCAA appeared to concede on one thing in the draft: the amount of control it has over NIL. Really, it just sets up a roundabout way to legislate NIL while hopefully shielding itself from lawsuits. 

But even this reform could anger the courts.

The Alston decision suggested the NCAA could be subject to another antitrust suit if it sets association-wide NIL rules. So the draft asks that every division, conference, and school write and publish their own regulations. 

The NCAA could make an argument that it’s legal for schools and conferences to set rules, Ehrlich said. But if a division tries to do so, the courts could see that as a problem. “I think that’s a gamble,” Ehrlich said.

The NCAA recognizes it has to both evolve and evade legal exposure. But it wants to ensure that its business model survives — and, clearly, that it can maintain as much control as possible.

At today’s Constitutional Convention, members will try to reconcile it all.

Tips? Comments? Reach out to Amanda Christovich at amanda@fos.company or on Twitter.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Inside NCAA Headquarters located in Indianapolis on Friday, March 10, 2023. Ncaa President Charlie Baker

NCAA Approves Plan to Let D-I College Athletes Bet on Pro Sports

The proposal still needs to be approved by D-II and D-III committees.
Sep 20, 2025; Lincoln, Nebraska, USA; Nebraska Cornhuskers head coach Matt Rhule walks onto the field before the game against the Michigan Wolverines at Memorial Stadium.

Big Ten Teams Grapple With Long Flights, Time-Zone Hurdles

Coaches across the country are noticing some impact.

Featured Today

Paul Cartier

Sports Organists Are Still Thriving in the Era of Raucous Arena Music

“When they walk out and they see a real organ guy, it’s like, ‘Wow.’”
Sep 27, 2025; Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA; Milwaukee Brewers center fielder Jackson Chourio (11) rounds the bases after hitting a home run during the sixth inning against the Cincinnati Reds at American Family Field.
October 4, 2025

Milwaukee Moneyball: Brewers Are Beating MLB’s Deeper Pockets

Milwaukee is holding its own against big-budget competitors.
Kōloa Rum Company Rum Rusher
September 27, 2025

Panthers Bubbly, Jets Wine, Manning Whiskey: The Sports Booze Boom

A sommelier dives into the sports booze trend—and tries Jets wine.
Nov 17, 2024; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers fans wave Terrible Towels against the Baltimore Ravens during the fourth quarter at Acrisure Stadium
September 26, 2025

Steelers’ Irish Roots Are Deeper Than NFL Dublin Game

The Steelers have history and the foundation for a future in Ireland.
Sep 1, 2025; Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA; North Carolina Tar Heels head coach Bill Belichick on the field before the game at Kenan Stadium

UNC’s Disastrous Season Continues With Report of NCAA Rules Violation

A UNC cornerbacks coach reportedly gave sideline passes to a player’s family.
Oct 4, 2025; Pasadena, California, USA; UCLA Bruins quarterback Nico Iamaleava (9) passes the ball during the fourth quarter against the Penn State Nittany Lions at Rose Bowl.
October 6, 2025

The Improbability of UCLA’s Incredible Upset Win Against Penn State

Before UCLA beat Penn State, donors were deeply unhappy.
Oct 4, 2025; Lincoln, Nebraska, USA; Nebraska Cornhuskers defensive back DeShon Singleton (8) celebrates after making an interception during the game against Michigan State at Memorial Stadium.
exclusive
October 7, 2025

Big Ten Considering Investment From California Pension Fund

Under the proposal, Big Ten would spin assets into a new entity.
Sponsored

How Jenny Just Is Shaping the Future of Sports Ownership

Jenny Just on bringing her investment experience to sports ownership.
Sep 27, 2025; University Park, Pennsylvania, USA; Penn State Nittany Lions head coach James Franklin reacts during the fourth quarter against the Oregon Ducks at Beaver Stadium.
October 6, 2025

Penn State Has a $50 Million James Franklin Problem

Franklin’s team lost to unranked UCLA on Saturday despite being heavy favorites.
October 5, 2025

CFB’s New Parity Era: Penn State, Texas Top-25 Exits Signal Shift

Penn State and Texas fall entirely out of the top-25 rankings.
Cody Campbell
October 4, 2025

Fox, ABC Reject Ad Accusing Power Conference Commissioners of Greed

Cody Campbell said the ads were pulled after he paid for them.
Florida State defensive back Renardo Green (8) tackles Miami running back Mark Fletcher Jr. (22) during a college football game Saturday, Nov. 11, 2023, at Doak Campbell Stadium in Tallahassee, Florida.
October 2, 2025

Miami–Florida State Rivalry Heats Up With Priciest Ticket in CFB

The get-in price for Saturday’s matchup in Tallahassee is more than $300.