• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 20, 2024
Join us this September for Tuned In Request to Attend

The Arguments

  • The crux of each argument lies in whether the Ninth Circuit properly applied antitrust law.
  • In essence, Alston lawyers say the NCAA’s ceiling on educational benefits violates antitrust, while the NCAA says amateurism is legal because it’s necessary to their business.
Photo: Charles Leclaire-USA TODAY/Design: Alex Brooks

There were three significant questions posed by the justices to the NCAA: 

What exactly is its definition of amateurism? Do consumers really watch NCAA sports over pro leagues because they’re not paid? Why is “price fixing” the cost of athlete labor not subject to strict antitrust scrutiny?

After they finished with the NCAA, the justices asked Alston’s lawyer: Would a favorable ruling “open the floodgates” to tear down NCAA sports as we know them?

Here are the arguments from the briefs that originally sparked these questions.

NCAA’s Side 

In its argument, the NCAA exploits its dual nature as both a business venture and an educational institution.

On the one hand, it says players have to be amateurs in order to make a unique, and therefore competitive, product. 

But on the other, since amateurism is used for primarily “educational” purposes — it’s alleged main objective — it shouldn’t be subject to strict antitrust scrutiny.

How does the NCAA prove it’s an “educational venture”? By qualifying that some of it’s sports, like women’s, don’t actually make money. 

“The argument never really made sense,” University of Baltimore law professor Dionne Koller told FOS. “It never made legal sense, and it doesn’t make logical sense.” 

“We know that gender equity and the free market can coexist.”

Alston’s Side

According to Alston plaintiffs, the NCAA can’t even come up with a clear definition of amateurism, given that scholarship rules have changed so much over time. They ask how amateurism could be essential if the NCAA can’t even define it.

And in order to prove the NCAA is, in fact, subject to antitrust law, Alston lawyers emphasize that the governing body acts more like a corporation than an educational charity.

One example the brief mentions: While normal students were asked to take classes remotely, football and basketball players have competed during the pandemic in order to satisfy lucrative TV contracts.

They also accuse the NCAA of asking for the equivalent of an exemption from antitrust law altogether, something a court can’t provide.

The NCAA, of course, denies this is true. Though experts told FOS that’s basically what they’re asking for.

Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

The Road to the Return of ‘EA Sports College Football’

This summer, the biggest development in college sports is virtual.
Jan 4, 2006; Pasadena, CA, USA: FILE PHOTO; Southern California Trojans running back Reggie Bush (5) in action against the Texas Longhorns during the 2006 Rose Bowl at the Rose Bowl. The Longhorns defeated the Trojans 41-38. Mandatory Credit: Richard Mackson-USA TODAY Network

The Most Watched College Football Games in U.S. TV History

The most-watched college football game in U.S. TV history is the 2006 Rose Bowl with 35.6 million viewers.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

‘EA Sports College Football 25’: It’s More Than a Game


Featured Today

Jan 7, 2024; Nashville, Tennessee, USA; Jacksonville Jaguars wide receiver Calvin Ridley (0) reacts after scoring a touchdown against the Tennessee Titans during the first half at Nissan Stadium.
July 14, 2024

Without Hard-Line Bans, Pro Athletes and Personnel Will Keep Betting on Sports

Penalties often aren’t stringent or consistent enough to deter banned behavior.
Oct 2, 2021; Miami Gardens, FL, USA; NFL commissioner Roger Goddell speaks during the Don Shula Celebration of Life at Hard Rock Stadium.
July 13, 2024

The NFL Is Confident It Can Overturn the Sunday Ticket Verdict

The league may have good reason to believe it can win.
July 8, 2024

NFLPA Report Cards Have Become the ‘Talk of the Locker Room’ Across..

NFLPA report cards have become the ‘talk of the locker room.’

Pac-12 Media Days Evolve Into a Cocktail Party at the Bellagio

The two-team ‘zombie conference’ is still hosting a football media day.
July 9, 2024

Arch Manning Will Be in EA’s ‘College Football 25’ After All

The NCAA’s most famous backup had previously opted out.
July 9, 2024

Big 12’s New Era Kicks Off: Expansion, Private Equity, and Global Ambitions

The new 16-team conference is holding media days in Las Vegas.

TopSpin 2K25 Brings the Legends of Tennis to Your Living Room

2K sports is reviving a classic with TopSpin 2K25.
July 8, 2024

Dan Hurley Finally Has New UConn Deal After Dramatic Offseason

Hurley is now the second-highest-paid coach in college basketball. 
July 7, 2024

The New College Sports Insiders Are Graphic Designers

Joe Tipton and Hayes Fawcett have become premier news-breakers on social media.
July 2, 2024

Navigating College Football’s 2024 Realignment Landscape: What’s Next?

Conferences are officially adding schools this summer.
April 13, 2024; Columbus, Ohio, USA; Ohio State Buckeyes wide receiver Emeka Egbuka (2) catches a pass for the scarlet team while defended by cornerback Jordan Hancock (7) of the grey team during the first half of the LifeSports Spring Game at Ohio Stadium on Saturday.
July 1, 2024

As NIL Turns Three, Collectives and Football Still Control the Industry

Collectives dominate NIL, and football makes up most of collective budgets.