• Loading stock data...
Sunday, March 30, 2025
Nominations Are Open for Front Office Sports Honors! Submit Now
Law

NASL Trial Could Get in Underbelly of American Soccer

If the opening arguments are any indication, the defunct league’s antitrust trial against MLS and U.S. Soccer could get explosive.

Don Garber
Jayne Kamin-Oncea-Imagn Images

The second iteration of the North American Soccer League was a lower-tier league that existed for only a handful of seasons, and it went defunct more than seven years ago. But a lawsuit the league filed attracted dozens of lawyers and an overflow courtroom in Brooklyn federal court Monday. That first day went more than six hours for opening arguments, and promised testimony from NBA royalty.

That’s because NASL’s antitrust trial against the U.S. Soccer Federation and Major League Soccer threatens to rip the veil off the cozy world of American professional soccer, with hundreds of millions of dollars at stake. 

NASL’s outside counsel, Jeff Kessler, is a titan of American sports law. He ripped into the dominant soccer organizations in his two-hour, 15-minute opening argument.

“It’s a small, insular world,” Kessler told the jury. “Either you belong or you don’t.” Of NASL chairman Rocco Commisso: “He wasn’t part of their club.”

NASL alleges MLS and USSF conspired to bar NASL from competing with MLS, and then further unjustly deprived the upstart league of renewing its Division II status—the second-highest level in the U.S. soccer pyramid—forcing its dissolution in 2018. MLS and USSF deny the two entities conspired, and contend NASL’s woes were caused by a major investor who was ensnared in the 2015 FIFA bribery scandal.

“Traffic was bailing out the league again and again and that came to an end,” USSF outside counsel Chris Yates told the jury, referring to NASL investor Traffic Sports. “The Traffic Sports crisis put the league into a downward spiral.”

The three-week trial, presuming there is not a settlement, will see the testimony of MLS commissioner Don Garber, FC Dallas and Kansas City Chiefs owner Clark Hunt, Big East commissioner Val Ackerman (she was a USSF board member during the period in question), and soon-to-be NBA Hall of Famer Carmelo Anthony, who owned the NASL Puerto Rican franchise.

Kessler described longtime soccer executive Sunil Gulati and Garber as “two peas in a pod.” Gulati had simultaneous roles with MLS and U.S. Soccer, and Kessler said he would call Gulati and Garber as witnesses to the allegedly illegal conspiracy between MLS and USSF. Lawyers for USSF and MLS strenuously argued there is and was nothing untoward about the MLS-USSF relationship, and Garber recused himself over the critical votes in question.

Those votes were by U.S. Soccer in 2015 to deny NASL’s bid for a Division I sanction on par with MLS, and in 2017 a denial of a renewal of its Division II sanction. At the heart of the dispute is whether the USSF used its power as the sport’s governing body in this country—giving it the right to sanction leagues—to protect MLS from NASL’s competition. 

NASL is suing for up to $170 million. The damages, if awarded, would be tripled under antitrust law.

Brad Ruskin, MLS’s outside counsel, told the jury it is “absurd” and “fictional” to argue MLS saw NASL as a competitive threat, listing the billions of dollars invested in MLS compared to the millions of dollars put into NASL.

“NASL was never a competitive threat,” he said. “NASL was just not on MLS’s mind.”

The coming weeks could get rancorous. Ruskin pointed out Anthony paid nothing for his team and only agreed to promote it. And he said the trial would reveal that Commisso, the colorful former NASL chairman who is funding the lawsuit, had a fake Twitter handle in 2017 he used to post nasty messages about the defendants.

Yates contemptuously referred to Kessler as having a “made for litigation argument,” warning the jury “he is trying to mislead you,” for using “smoke and mirrors” and “playing tricks.”  Kessler and Yates are also currently on opposite sides of the lawsuit brought by Michael Jordan over the NASCAR charter system; Kessler is also the lead attorney for the plaintiffs in the landmark House v. NCAA case.

Kessler offered as proof of unfair treatment that USSF granted waivers to MLS over the years allowing it not to meet stadium capacity thresholds and other standards necessary to secure a Division I sanction, while denying them to NASL in its 2015 bid.

But Ruskin argued when USSF agreed to a sanction and allowed standards waivers, there were reasons for this: a team, for example, moving into a smaller facility while building a new one.  When NASL was turned away for waivers, he said, it was over poor business plans.

“NASL never met U.S. Soccer’s minimum standards,” Yates said. “It just never put in the work, never built those stadiums, never went out and signed great players.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Columbia, SC - February 16, 2025 - Colonial Life Arena: Rebecca Lobo and Ryan Ruocco during a regular season game.

Inside Ryan Ruocco’s Rapid Rise to ESPN’s Top Voice of Women’s Hoops

The top voice became “quickly addicted” to calling the women’s game.

Duke Keeps ACC Alive in March Madness

Duke will represent the ACC in the Elite Eight in both tournaments.
TCU Horned Frogs guard Hailey Van Lith (10) celebrates as she heads to the locker room after winning the NCAA Playoff Regional semi-final game against Notre Dame at Legacy Arena in Birmingham Alabama, March 29, 2025.

Hailey Van Lith Is an Early Success Story of Unrestricted Transfer Portal

She becomes first player to reach the Elite Eight with three teams.
Mar 27, 2025; Newark, NJ, USA; Alabama Crimson Tide guard Chris Youngblood (8) and the Alabama Crimson Tide bench celebrate during the second half against the Brigham Young Cougars during an East Regional semifinal of the 2025 NCAA tournament at Prudential Center.

How Alabama Became College Basketball’s Newest Juggernaut

The Crimson Tide have found success rivaling their historic football program.

Featured Today

Kendall Coyne Schofield

Kendall Coyne Schofield Wants More for the Next Wave of Mom-Athletes

The Walter Cup–winning Frost captain says small changes mean “everything.”
Dec 21, 2024; Hartford, Connecticut, USA; UConn Huskies guard Paige Bueckers (5) looks to pass the ball against USC Trojans guard JuJu Watkins (12) in the first half at XL Center.
March 23, 2025

‘More Value to Be Had’: Were Women’s March Madness Media Rights Undersold?

Could the NCAA have gotten millions more in its latest TV deal?
Mar 20, 2025; Lexington, KY, USA; Creighton Bluejays forward Jasen Green (0) dunks the ball during the second half against the Louisville Cardinals in the first round of the NCAA Tournament at Rupp Arena
March 22, 2025

Basketball-Only Schools Could See Power Surge After House Settlement Approval 

Football teams might monopolize the revenue-sharing dollars at power conference schools.
Mar 15, 2025; New York, NY, USA; St. John's Red Storm guard RJ Luis Jr. (12) after hitting a three-point basket against the Creighton Bluejays in the second half at Madison Square Garden.
March 20, 2025

Perfect Storm: St. John’s Biggest Fans Can’t Bet on the School

In the No. 1 sports betting market, the Red Storm are off-limits.
Feb 5, 2025; New Orleans, LA, USA; The ESPN logo at the Super Bowl LIX media center at the Ernest N. Morial Convention Center.
exclusive

ESPN Is Accused of Harassment, Retaliation in Legal Letter From Exec Editor

Cristina Daglas has been on administrative leave since January.
Juan Soto
March 18, 2025

MLBPA’s NIL Suit Against DraftKings Can Continue, Judge Says

The sportsbook failed to get the case dismissed.
A set of trading cards
March 19, 2025

New Suit Alleges Fanatics ‘Monopoly’ Increased Trading Card Prices 

The suit also names the NBA, NHL, and NFL as defendants.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
Nick Kyrgios reacts to a point against Botic van de Zandschulp in the first set of their first-round match at the BNP Paribas Open in Indian Wells, Calif., Thursday, March 6, 2025.
March 18, 2025

Novak Djokovic’s PTPA Sues Tennis ‘Cartel’

The 163-page lawsuit was filed in three countries and seeks to reshape the sport.
Jan 5, 2025; Glendale, Arizona, USA; Arizona Cardinals wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. (18) and tight end Trey McBride (85) against the San Francisco 49ers at State Farm Stadium.
March 14, 2025

Marvin Harrison Jr., Fanatics End 10-Month-Long Legal Battle

Fanatics initially filed the lawsuit last May for breach of contract.
Dec. 18, 1982; New York, NY, USA; FILE PHOTO; Miami Dolphins quarterback David Woodley (16) is pursued by New York Jets defensive end Mark Gastineau (99) at the Orange Bowl.
March 13, 2025

Mark Gastineau Sues ESPN for $25 Million, Alleging Deceptive Editing of Favre..

Gastineau is a Pro Football Hall of Famer who played from 1979 to 1988.
Ryan Wedding
March 7, 2025

Feds Put $10 Million Bounty on Olympic Snowboarder for Drug Trafficking, Murder

Ryan Wedding competed at the 2002 Winter Games for Canada.