• Loading stock data...
Wednesday, July 16, 2025
Law

NASL Loses Antitrust Lawsuit Against MLS, U.S. Soccer

The defunct soccer league had been seeking $170 million in damages. If it won, the NASL could have been owed more than $500 million.

Dec 9, 2023; Columbus, OH, USA; Columbus Crew forward Cucho Hernandez (9) celebrates scoring a goal in front of Los Angeles FC goalkeeper Maxime Crepeau (16) during the MLS Cup final at Lower.com Field.
Imagn Images

A jury has found for the defense in an antitrust lawsuit brought by the defunct North American Soccer League (NASL) against the U.S. Soccer Federation (USSF) and Major League Soccer (MLS).

After a three-week trial, deliberations took a mere two hours.

“We are pleased the jury has recognized the lack of merit in NASL’s claims and ruled in our favor, bringing this unfounded litigation to a close,” said USSF in a statement. “This decision validates U.S. Soccer’s commitment to fostering a broad and healthy ecosystem of professional soccer leagues across all divisions.”

The NASL that brought the lawsuit should not be confused with the top-tier league that boasted Pelé and Johan Cruyff. Instead, it was an unaffiliated reboot that languished in a lower rung of the American soccer’s league system starting in 2011. After U.S. Soccer didn’t renew its Division II status in 2017, it quickly folded. The league then sued the federation and MLS, which comprises Division I, arguing they colluded to keep the upstart league out.

The NASL had been seeking $170 million in damages in a Brooklyn federal court, but most of the actual damages will hit only the plaintiff’s already diminished reputation. (If NASL had won, the $170 million in damages could have been tripled under antitrust law to more than $500 million, however, the judge ruled in the defense’s favor to reduce the potential damages by $375 million.)

During discovery, former NASL chairman Rocco Commisso was found to have used a burner Twitter account to bad-mouth MLS commissioner Don Garber and USSF president Sunil Gulati, comparing them to Harvey Weinstein and Bernie Madoff.

When future Hall of Famer Carmelo Anthony, who owned NASL club Puerto Rico FC from 2015 to 2017, testified for the plaintiffs, things got worse. Judge Hector Gonzalez wondered aloud what his testimony had to do with the case, which was brought not by owners but by the league. Had the NASL won, Gonzalez was considering changing the damages instructions to make clear that owner losses should not be included.

In the end, the jury agreed with the defense given by MLS: That the NASL went bust because of bad business decisions, not due to any nefarious collaboration between USSF and its biggest league. 

The legal saga might not be over, however. NASL counsel Jeff Kessler told Front Office Sports: “We have great respect for the jury process, but there were some fundamental legal errors made which prevented the jurors from receiving important evidence or being instructed on the correct legal standards and claims. Our client accordingly expects to appeal.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

exclusive

Tennis Hall of Fame Rejects Bill Ackman’s $10M Gift

The Hall of Fame said it wants to avoid “any perception of impropriety.”
Mar 31, 2025; Washington, District of Columbia, USA; Miami Heat guard Terry Rozier (2) drives to the basket against Washington Wizards guard AJ Johnson (5) during the first quarter at Capital One Arena.

Terry Rozier’s Attorney Confirms He’s Still Under Federal Gambling Probe

Rozier finished the season playing for the Heat despite the federal probe.
Wyndham Clark

Oakmont Bans Golfer Wyndham Clark After Locker Room Rampage

He’ll have to donate and seek treatment to get reinstated.

Featured Today

2025 PDC World Darts Championship Final - Luke Littler vs Michael Van Gerwen

A Teen Darts Prodigy Is Becoming Bigger Than the Game Itself

Luke ‘The Nuke’ Littler is cashing in on his devastatingly accurate shot.
May 31, 2025; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Sydney McLaughin-Levrone (USA) reacts before the women's 100m hurdles during the Grand Slam Track Philadelphia at Franklin Field
exclusive
July 13, 2025

Track’s New Money Is Running Into Old Problems

The sport’s big-money era has hit some speed bumps in 2025.
Bobbleheads are seen at Vintage Indy Sports, Tuesday, April 29, 2025 in Speedway. The local sports memorabilia store opened recently.
July 12, 2025

Baseball’s Bobbleheads Are the Center of the Collectibles Universe

Baseball’s most important keepsake drives long lines—and big business.
Rimouski, QC - JUNE 1: Final Game of the 2025 Memorial Cup between the Medicine Hats Tigers and the London Knights on June 1, 2025, at the Colisée Financière Sun Life in Rimouski, Qc.
July 11, 2025

CHL Is Facing a ‘Pandora’s Box’ of Questions Amid NCAA Talent Departure

As players defect to college, the Canadian Hockey League won’t cede ground.

Judge Rules for NFL, Fanatics Against Small Apparel Seller

The lawsuit argued the NFL “aids and abets” Fanatics with its strategy.
A set of trading cards
July 9, 2025

Judge Rules Against Fanatics as Panini Case Gets Rancorous

A judge ordered Fanatics to turn over unredacted trading card licenses.
Caster Semenya
July 10, 2025

Caster Semenya’s Legal Win Could Reopen Fight Against Testosterone Limits

The Olympian champion’s appeal against gender eligibility rules continues.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
May 9, 2024; Columbus, OH, USA; Sports are shown on TVs behind the bar as guests enjoy the grand opening of DraftKings Sports & Social in the Short North. Though there are no on-site betting windows, eligible customers can place bets through the DraftKings app.
July 3, 2025

PrizePicks Drops Suit Against Ex-Employee Who Left for DraftKings

The ex-employee still disputes the allegations.
Wander Franco
June 26, 2025

Wander Franco Convicted of Child Sex Abuse, Receives 2-Year Suspended Sentence

Franco can avoid jail time but is unlikely to return to MLB.
Wimbledon
June 25, 2025

Players Suing Tennis Begin Negotiations With Grand Slams

They may add the Slams as defendants if talks fail in 90 days.
Dec 24, 2022; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson (4) warms up before the game between the Browns and the New Orleans Saints at FirstEnergy Stadium
June 24, 2025

Unearthed NFL Arbitration Ruling Raises More Questions Than Answers

The NFL was cleared of collusion, but new questions have emerged.