• Loading stock data...
Sunday, August 17, 2025
Stephen A. Smith vs Clay Travis at Tuned In on September 16 in NYC. Don’t miss it. Buy tickets now!

MLB’s Flagship Store Will Be Tested By Timid Sports Retail Sales Trends

  • Merchandise sales for MLB, NBA, and the NFL are all flat or down in the high single digits over the last 12 months, NPD says.
  • The new outpost, set to open in Manhattan in 2020, will be the only official MLB league store location made available in the U.S.
customers at mlb distributor location
Photo Credit: Thomas B. Shea-USA TODAY Sports

Major League Baseball expects its flagship retail store, set to open next year, to be a sanctuary for baseball fans to nerd out while also driving revenue.

That’s according to MLB’s SVP of Consumer Products Denis Nolan, who said that after kicking around the idea of a flagship store in the U.S. internally for several years, the league found the right location and right partner in Legends Project Development to operate the 17,000-square-foot store that is now under construction. 

“We are providing a really elevated fan experience on the retail side and on fan engagement,” said Nolan. “Visitors to New York will know this is the premier place for MLB to promote merchandise and our offerings.”

Two factors traditionally drive merchandise sales across professional sports leagues: Players moving to a new team and new-found success by clubs, according to Matt Powell, senior sports industry advisor at the NPD Group. Out of the remaining teams in the 2019 MLB playoffs, the Washington Nationals winning the World Series would bring the biggest boost to league merchandise sales.

NPD Group tracks revenue for all licensed apparel sold by official league distributors, including Modell’s, Dick’s Sporting Goods, and Fanatics. Over the last 12 months, the sale of MLB merchandise is down in the high single digits, according to the company. The NBA is flat over the same period, while the NFL is down in the low single digits. 

“Sports apparel has never been stronger and licensed apparel should move in concert with it, but it has just not happened,” said Powell. “You’ll see fans wearing licensed apparel in a stadium, but not on the street.”  

Recent trends also show that league stores are usually not profitable in New York City, where commercial real estate is expensive, and a lot of space is required to showcase team memorabilia. Sports leagues instead are more apt to view retail openings in The Big Apple as a way to market themselves and connect with fans in the city with the most foot traffic in the U.S., said Powell.

“New York City stores are the same for all leagues, brands, and other large retailers. They are more about marketing and less about commerce,” he added. 

READ MORE: Kobe Bryant Increases Chinese Presence through New Web Store

The new flagship retail space will offer products from all 30 clubs, historical franchises in the Cooperstown Collection, and game-worn gear. An adjacent courtyard will additionally be used to host events and marketing activations. 

In opening the long-awaited flagship store, MLB also selected prime real estate. Located at 1271 Avenue of the Americas, across the street from Radio City Music Hall, the space is in close proximity to both the NBA and NHL stores. Each league has had a presence in New York City for more than a decade. In addition to the store, MLB is  also consolidating its two existing New York offices and moving into the same building.

“I don’t think those stores really compete with each other,” said Nolan, speaking to the threat of competition from the NHL and NBA outposts. “As a baseball fan, this will be on your checklist of things to do in New York.”

“Midtown has tourists walking up and down all day, and is a major shopping area,” Powell added.  “The same way you see a Burger King across the street from a McDonald’s; you want to get some of that traffic.”

READ MORE: MLB Ticketing Revenue Expected To Increase in 2019, Amid Another Attendance Drop

MLB will not open any other stores in the U.S. The league, however, does have multiple retail store locations open across Asia with operating partners. These stores, while still offering officially licensed MLB apparel, tend to cater more to lifestyle or fashion enthusiats than hardcore sports fans.

“The team logo does not mean as much,” Nolan said.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

As NFL Eyes Overseas Growth, UK Ambassador Pushes for Super Bowl

Britain’s ambassador to the U.S. is the latest to pursue the game.
Braintree American batter Ryan Fennell hits the ball against Southeast pitcher Brody Miller during the Little League Baseball World Series at South Williamsport, PA on Thursday, Aug. 13, 2025.

Little League International Condemns Youth Sports Gambling Amid World Series

Licensed sportsbooks prevent gambling on the LLWS and similar events.

NFL Preseason Week 1 Delivers Record Audience for NFL Network

The channel averaged 2.1 million viewers for its eight live telecasts.

Featured Today

‘Labubu Gang’: The Creepy-Cute Dolls Sweeping Pro Sports

The creepy-cute doll is the hottest collectible—and fashion statement.
Middle Tennessee wide receiver Cam'ron Lacy (86) catches a pass and carries the ball during the season final home football game against New Mexico State on Saturday, Nov. 23, 2024.
August 15, 2025

How Middle Tennessee State Added $668,000 to Its NIL Budget

The Blue Raiders are creating a new blueprint for cutting costs.
Bridgewater American 12U Little League player Micah Poulter holds a District 7 pin during a send-off rally to the New England regional tournament in Bristol, Connecticut, from Legion Field on Friday, August 2, 2024.
August 14, 2025

Inside the Little League World Series Pin Trade

The rare little collectibles fuel a frenzy in Williamsport each summer.
Schultz of Israel-Premier Tech
August 12, 2025

Rice Krispies Treats Are Upending the Billion-Dollar Athlete-Fuel Wars

The world’s most elite athletes are eating like first graders.
Sponsored

Game the Green: Transforming Fan Experiences at TPC Sawgrass

As fans gather at THE PLAYERS Championship, Comcast Business will be keeping spectators and the PGA TOUR connected like never before.
Sponsored

How Sportradar and the NBA Are Shaping the Future of Immersive Fan..

By transforming raw data into tailored, interactive content, Sportradar helps turn the NBA’s enormous fanbase into active participants.
February 3, 2025

Super Bowl Ticket Prices Crash As Hotel Rooms See Historic Rate Hike

Prices sink by about 30%, due in part to a lodging crunch.
Sponsored

‘Run With the Competition’: Ultra Trail Runner Lotti Brinks Is Back With..

Ultrarunner Lotti Brinks is ready to make her first Courmayeur-Champex-Chamonix podium in her HOKA Mafate 5s.
October 8, 2024

NBA GMs Rank Salary-Cap Apron As Rule That Needs to Change Most

Schedule changes finished second with 17% of the vote.
Sponsored

Trend Report: Chiefs-Chargers, Tobacco Road Rivalry, Nebraska Sellout Streak

According to data from TickPick, some games this week will prove to be wallet-busters, climbing into the four figures.
September 8, 2024

US Open Breaks Attendance Record

Top-seeded Jannik Sinner beat No. 12 Taylor Fritz in straight sets Sunday.
Sponsored

Mastercard’s Foodies & Fairways: Where Golf Meets Gourmet at the TOUR Championship

This year’s TOUR Championship in Atlanta isn’t just about world-class golf—it’s also a celebration of local flavors.