• Loading stock data...
Thursday, April 3, 2025
Nominations Are Open for Front Office Sports Honors! Submit Now

Manchester City and Premier League Both Claim Victory in Major Panel Ruling

  • A panel found some Premier League financial rules were ‘unlawful.’
  • Both club and league called the panel’s ruling favorable.
Kyle Robertson-USA TODAY Sports

Manchester City won a narrow victory against the English Premier League last month in a ruling that was released to its clubs and the public Monday.

An arbitration panel of retired judges ruled that some Premier League rules blocking City from doing sponsorship deals with companies that had shared ownership with teams were “unlawful.”

However, it was a highly technical ruling that saw both Manchester City and the Premier League issue statements Monday declaring victory in the case. The ruling is from a separate panel than the one hearing the league’s 115 financial charges against City, although the sponsorship deals play heavily into those charges. (In 2018, Der Spiegel reported City’s owners fudged its books by hiding the true worth of its sponsorship deals with companies with the same owners.)

The Premier League bylaws governing sponsorship deals are called the Associated Party Transaction rules, and City asked for the APT system to be thrown out entirely. The panel did not do so.

It did rule that:

  • The league was wrong to block City’s sponsorship deals with Abu Dhabi–owned Etihad Airways and First Etihad Bank.
  • The APT system as a whole was legal, but how the league heard challenges to rulings in the system was “procedurally unfair.”
  • The APT rules were “unlawful” to “exclude from their scope shareholder loans.” Loans from ownership to team operations are widespread in the Premier League and sports generally.
  • It added that “for no other reason” were the APT rules illegal.

The complex ruling had both sides thanking the arbitration panel.

“The Premier League welcomes the Tribunal’s findings, which endorsed the overall objectives, framework and decision-making of the APT system,” the league said in a statement. “The Tribunal upheld the need for the APT system as a whole and rejected the majority of Manchester City’s challenges. Moreover, the Tribunal found that the Rules are necessary in order for the League’s financial controls to be effective.”

That’s one way to spin it. The other was how Manchester City reacted. “The Club has succeeded with its claim: the Associated Party Transaction (APT) rules have been found to be unlawful and the Premier League’s decisions on two specific MCFC sponsorship transactions have been set aside,” it said in a lengthy statement on its website. “The Premier League was found to have abused its dominant position.”

The team has been the leading power in English soccer since Mansour bin Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan of the United Arab Emirates’ sovereign wealth fund purchased it in 2008. City has won the league four years in a row and six of the last seven years. Its detractors—and the Premier League’s 115 charges—argue that City won those laurels by buying an expensive, star-studded roster in ways that broke Premier League financial rules. One Premier League owner told Front Office Sports in August that he believes the trial—still ongoing in London—will end with the Citizens being relegated.

Some English media reports have speculated the ruling could mean that teams like Arsenal and Brighton, which rely heavily on shareholder loans, could be in trouble. Arsenal was among the teams that gave evidence for the Premier League in front of the arbitration panel. It’s possible, although it seems unlikely, that the ruling means ownership loans to teams will now have to charge commercial interest rates instead of the low- or zero-interest-rate loans some owners make now.

City has no debt to its owners, while, for example, the Kroenkes have loaned Arsenal hundreds of millions of dollars at little interest. In front of the arbitration panel, City said that “such loans are obviously APTs” and no different than City’s sponsorship deals. The panel agreed.

The league introduced the APT rules in 2021 after Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund bought Newcastle United, an attempt to curb the influence of the billions of dollars of Gulf oil money flowing into English soccer. 

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Baseball action between South Fork High School at St. Lucie West Centennial on Wednesday, April 2, 2025, in Port St. Lucie. Centennial wins in the top of the the 7th inning, 6-3.

Private Equity’s Youth Sports Push Continues With MaxPreps Deal

The deal follows a string of other recent PE transactions in the youth sports space.
Mar 30, 2025; Indianapolis, IN, USA; Houston Cougars head coach Kelvin Sampson reacts after cutting the net for the Midwest Regional final of the 2025 NCAA tournament at Lucas Oil Stadium.

‘Overlooked’ Big 12 Has Quietly Succeeded During Men’s March Madness

Big 12 commissioner Brett Yormark says the conference has won big, too.
Sep 16, 2023; Stanford, California, USA; Sacramento State Hornets players pose for a photo after the game against the Stanford Cardinal at Stanford Stadium.

Sacramento State Applies for Waiver to Transition to FBS

The Hornets would need the NCAA to approve a waiver to switch to FBS.

Featured Today

Dec 27, 2024; San Jose, California, USA; San Jose Sharks center Macklin Celebrini (71) skates during warm ups before their game against the Vegas Golden Knights at SAP Center at San Jose

Macklin Celebrini and the Sharks Rookies Have Brought Good Vibes to a..

The rookie’s arrival has boosted spirits incongruously high inside the flagging franchise.
Mar 26, 2025; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James (23) in the first half Indiana Pacers at Gainbridge Fieldhouse.
April 1, 2025

The Creator Behind the LeBron ‘Glazing’ Trend Sweeping TikTok

FOS spoke to TikTok user OkaySpade who made the original song.
Mar 22, 2025; Providence, RI, USA; McNeese State Cowboys manager Amir Khan before a second round men’s NCAA Tournament game against the Purdue Boilermakers at Amica Mutual Pavilion
April 1, 2025

Inside the 24-Hour NIL March Madness Deals

Some of the most viral partnerships come together overnight.
Seattle Kraken
April 1, 2025

Samantha Holloway Is Seattle’s NHL Present—and Hopeful NBA Future

Samantha Holloway is steering the Kraken and hoping to revive pro hoops.
Jessica Pegula

Jessica Pegula on Tennis: Pay, Saudi Deals, and Women’s Sports Boom

Pegula wants tennis players to receive more prize money.
Los Angeles Golf Club owners Alexis Ohanian and Serena Williams cheer for their team against the New York Golf Club during the TGL semifinal match at SoFi Center on March 17, 2025, in Palm Beach Gardens, Florida.
exclusive
April 1, 2025

Alexis Ohanian Bid on NFL Flag Football, Serena Williams Exploring Franchise

Ohanian is the first known bidder for the flag football leagues.
Kelly Coleman, pro bat lead operator, inspects a torpedo bat after it comes out of a baseball bat lathe at the Louisville Slugger Museum & Factory in Louisville, Ky. on Mar. 31, 2025.
April 2, 2025

‘Torpedo’ Bat Sales Boom As Debate Rages About Effectiveness

Several manufacturers report historic interest in the much-debated bat design.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
April 1, 2025

Goodell, Owners Signal 18-Game NFL Season Is Coming—Eventually

The idea of a longer schedule ties into several other league initiatives.
Laney-Hamilton
April 1, 2025

WNBA Champion Missing Season Shows Risks and Kinks of Unrivaled

The Liberty have six weeks to make a decision on Betnijah Laney-Hamilton.
Nov 10, 2024; Munich, Germany; The NFL shield logo at midfield during the 2024 NFL Munich Game at Allianz Arena.
April 1, 2025

NFL’s Global Ambitions Now Extend to Abu Dhabi

Three teams gain marketing rights to the United Arab Emirates.
April 1, 2025

NFL Tush Push Vote Has Been Pushed

Owners table a vote on the highly debated quarterback sneak play.