• Loading stock data...
Saturday, April 26, 2025

Manchester City and Premier League Both Claim Victory in Major Panel Ruling

  • A panel found some Premier League financial rules were ‘unlawful.’
  • Both club and league called the panel’s ruling favorable.
Kyle Robertson-USA TODAY Sports

Manchester City won a narrow victory against the English Premier League last month in a ruling that was released to its clubs and the public Monday.

An arbitration panel of retired judges ruled that some Premier League rules blocking City from doing sponsorship deals with companies that had shared ownership with teams were “unlawful.”

However, it was a highly technical ruling that saw both Manchester City and the Premier League issue statements Monday declaring victory in the case. The ruling is from a separate panel than the one hearing the league’s 115 financial charges against City, although the sponsorship deals play heavily into those charges. (In 2018, Der Spiegel reported City’s owners fudged its books by hiding the true worth of its sponsorship deals with companies with the same owners.)

The Premier League bylaws governing sponsorship deals are called the Associated Party Transaction rules, and City asked for the APT system to be thrown out entirely. The panel did not do so.

It did rule that:

  • The league was wrong to block City’s sponsorship deals with Abu Dhabi–owned Etihad Airways and First Etihad Bank.
  • The APT system as a whole was legal, but how the league heard challenges to rulings in the system was “procedurally unfair.”
  • The APT rules were “unlawful” to “exclude from their scope shareholder loans.” Loans from ownership to team operations are widespread in the Premier League and sports generally.
  • It added that “for no other reason” were the APT rules illegal.

The complex ruling had both sides thanking the arbitration panel.

“The Premier League welcomes the Tribunal’s findings, which endorsed the overall objectives, framework and decision-making of the APT system,” the league said in a statement. “The Tribunal upheld the need for the APT system as a whole and rejected the majority of Manchester City’s challenges. Moreover, the Tribunal found that the Rules are necessary in order for the League’s financial controls to be effective.”

That’s one way to spin it. The other was how Manchester City reacted. “The Club has succeeded with its claim: the Associated Party Transaction (APT) rules have been found to be unlawful and the Premier League’s decisions on two specific MCFC sponsorship transactions have been set aside,” it said in a lengthy statement on its website. “The Premier League was found to have abused its dominant position.”

The team has been the leading power in English soccer since Mansour bin Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan of the United Arab Emirates’ sovereign wealth fund purchased it in 2008. City has won the league four years in a row and six of the last seven years. Its detractors—and the Premier League’s 115 charges—argue that City won those laurels by buying an expensive, star-studded roster in ways that broke Premier League financial rules. One Premier League owner told Front Office Sports in August that he believes the trial—still ongoing in London—will end with the Citizens being relegated.

Some English media reports have speculated the ruling could mean that teams like Arsenal and Brighton, which rely heavily on shareholder loans, could be in trouble. Arsenal was among the teams that gave evidence for the Premier League in front of the arbitration panel. It’s possible, although it seems unlikely, that the ruling means ownership loans to teams will now have to charge commercial interest rates instead of the low- or zero-interest-rate loans some owners make now.

City has no debt to its owners, while, for example, the Kroenkes have loaned Arsenal hundreds of millions of dollars at little interest. In front of the arbitration panel, City said that “such loans are obviously APTs” and no different than City’s sponsorship deals. The panel agreed.

The league introduced the APT rules in 2021 after Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund bought Newcastle United, an attempt to curb the influence of the billions of dollars of Gulf oil money flowing into English soccer. 

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

NFL Draft Round 1 Draws 13.6M Viewers, Second-Highest Ever

With stars staying on the board, viewers tuned in.

Five QBs Drafted As Shedeur Sanders Slips to Fourth Round

Shedeur Sanders is still waiting after slipping out of the first round.

Ohio State’s $20M Roster Sends 7 Players to NFL in First Two..

The NIL-fueled title team had more draftees than all of the Big 12.

Trump Defends Sanders After Snub: ‘What Is Wrong With NFL Owners?’

He said Shedeur Sanders has “phenomenal genes” and asked if owners are “stupid.”

Featured Today

Apr 13, 2025; Tampa, Florida, USA; Tampa Bay Rays center fielder Jake Mangum (28) scores a run against the Atlanta Braves in the sixth inning at George M. Steinbrenner Field.

The Rays Groundskeepers Are Adjusting to Life Outside the Dome

After nearly three decades in a dome, Tampa groundskeepers were forced outside.
April 25, 2025

The Former NBA Agent Who Became a Pickleball Deputy Commissioner

Chris Patrick went from representing Jimmy Butler to pickleball deputy commissioner.
Apr 5, 2025; San Antonio, TX, USA; Duke Blue Devils forward Cooper Flagg (2) reacts after a three point basket against the Houston Cougars during the first half in the semifinals of the men's Final Four of the 2025 NCAA Tournament at the Alamodome.
April 21, 2025

Cooper Flagg’s Timing Is Perfect for the NBA and USA Basketball

The projected No. 1 pick just declared for the draft.
Apr 14, 2025; New York, New York, USA; Paige Bueckers is interviewed by ESPN after being selected with the number one overall pick to the Dallas Wings in the 2025 WNBA Draft at The Shed at Hudson Yards
April 21, 2025

ESPN’s WNBA Coverage Mirrors the League’s Stunning Growth

“I don’t think we stand still in our coverage of women’s sports,” says Rowe.

NFL Draft Attendance in Green Bay Easily Tops Early Projections

Round 1 drew 205,000 fans in and around Lambeau Field.
MLB Speedway Classic rendering
April 24, 2025

Baseball Meets Bristol: Braves-Reds Game Aims for Record Crowd

Playing an MLB game inside a racetrack brings unique challenges.
Sponsored

Fighting for Clarity: Inside UFC’s New Partnership With Total Wireless

UFC teams with Total Wireless in a no-frills partnership built for today’s mobile-first, value-driven fanbase.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

This week, Two-time Super Bowl Champion and CBS NFL analyst Logan Ryan joins us to talk the business of sports on our third installment of Portfolio Players.
April 24, 2025

Fewer NFL Draft Prospects Will Be in Green Bay. Here’s Why

There will be 15 NFL Draft prospects in Green Bay.
Vancouver
April 23, 2025

PWHL Picks Vancouver for First Expansion Team

More than 19,000 fans attended a game in Vancouver in January.
USL
April 23, 2025

USL Super League Sells Its Name in Push for Soccer Relevance

The deal was for seven figures.
April 23, 2025

NHL’s U.S. Playoff TV Ratings Down 27% in Early Games

This season’s numbers were down 12% compared to the 2023–2024 season.