• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 5, 2025
opinion
Finance

Nike’s New CEO Choice Was Cheered. Now He Must Fix the Brand

  • After a brutal year for Nike, it pushed out CEO John Donahoe and named Elliott Hill its new CEO, to applause from Nike watchers and Wall Street.
  • He has a lot to do to repair the brand, and Under Armour CEO Kevin Plank will be watching.
Sep 11, 2024; Los Angeles, California, USA; The Nike shoes worn by Seattle Storm center Mercedes Russell in the first half against the LA Sparks at Crypto.com Arena.
Kirby Lee/Imagn Images
Bill Ackman
Exclusive

Billionaire Bill Ackman Prepares for ‘Once in a Lifetime’ Tennis Match in Newport

Ackman says he's "peaking next week" at the Hall of Fame Open.
Read Now
July 4, 2025 |

On June 27, Nike stock closed the day at $94.19 per share. Then the company reported its fiscal fourth-quarter earnings, including a bad surprise: the long-dominant Oregon apparel giant cut its full-year guidance and warned it expects a 10% sales drop in its first quarter. When the market closed June 28, the stock price had tanked 20% to $75.37.

It was Nike stock’s worst day ever, and CEO John Donahoe, who took the job in 2020, did not survive the drop. (A Bloomberg story on Sept. 13 that called Donahoe the “man who made Nike uncool” and reported he “pissed off partners and disappointed fans” didn’t help.) On Sept. 19, the company parted ways with Donahoe and announced Elliott Hill, a popular company veteran, will take the CEO reins starting Oct. 14. 

The stock has rebounded 10% since then. Employees at the Beaverton HQ have rejoiced. Some of the LinkedIn posts from Nike watchers are downright euphoric. Veteran sneaker analyst Matt Powell wrote that Sept. 19 “will go down as one of the greatest days in Nike history” and that Hill will take Nike “out of the dark days.”

But Hill has a lot of work to do to validate those cheers.

First, on Oct. 1 we’ll get Nike earnings and find out if its July through September quarter was indeed as bad as warnings indicated. That won’t be on Hill’s shoulders, and optimism about his appointment might soften the blow anyway—that and the fact that shareholders are already bracing for impact.

Then Hill’s work will begin. 

What was wrong at Nike, and how much of it can really be blamed on one leader? These are the broad strokes

  • Too much emphasis on its direct-to-consumer business (no wonder, Donahoe is the former CEO of eBay) to the detriment of Nike’s relationships with brick-and-mortar retailers (crucial in sneakerland).
  • Too much discounting on its own web site, which dilutes the brand.
  • A lack of innovation (ain’t that always the line when long-dominant brands dip? Look at Adidas) and a range of failed initiatives, combined with a three-year-long cost-cutting effort that included laying off 1,500 people.
  • The brand has lost that elusive “cool factor” to rapidly rising upstarts like On, Hoka, and even non-upstarts like New Balance, Asics, and Brooks that all understand running is the leading style segment now. (The WSJ pinpointed in June the rise of the social running club, and how Nike blew its pole position with amateur runners.)

These problems won’t magically dissipate just because Hill is now The Guy. He can put new systems in place to fix many of them, but his bigger task is more intangible: refresh the brand. By the way, its latest campaign, “Winning Isn’t For Everyone,” was not well received.  

Nike Isn’t the Only Brand in Need of a Refresh

Over in Baltimore, Under Armour founder Kevin Plank has been trying to refresh his brand for years, as the one-time fearsome challenger to Nike and Adidas is on a long decline. Under Armour’s latest earnings report, from its fiscal first quarter, showed just about every metric down, including apparel sales, footwear sales, and even profit, but the numbers weren’t as bad as analysts expected, and the company revised its guidance higher, so the stock gained.

Plank, a former Maryland football player, created a brand in 1996 that was extremely defined—arguably too defined. Its iconic product was a sweat-wicking shirt for lifting weights and playing football. Its motto was “Protect this house.” Its image was of tough, muscled men. The company has been trying to get away from that for a decade. But it has proven extremely difficult to get consumers to see Under Armour in a different light.

Amid its own specific struggles and broader industry headwinds, Plank put himself back in the CEO role in March, replacing CEO Stephanie Linnartz, who had announced a three-year plan to fix the company, but was given less than one year. The signal: Only our founder himself can revive the brand. 

In a way, Nike is sending the same signal: that a company insider with the trust and love of the staff (Hill) will succeed where an outsider (Donahoe) couldn’t. But brand is a squishy, elusive thing. Adidas went all-in on Kanye West in 2015 to halt its long sneaker market share decline, and that move worked—until it blew up

Making an apparel brand cool again takes a very long time, and requires changes at every level of the business, at every venue where the brand shows up to consumers. The swoosh has a long-established lead in the sportswear race, but challengers are rounding the turn and eyeing the podium.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Baseball’s Celebrity Row: Behind MLB’s First-Pitch Ritual

Often planned, sometimes spontaneous, the ritual throw is baseball’s celebrity row.
Bill Ackman
exclusive

Billionaire Bill Ackman Prepares for ‘Once in a Lifetime’ Tennis Match in..

Ackman says he’s “peaking next week” at the Hall of Fame Open.

3,000 Hot Dogs, $20K in Prizes: Behind the Nathan’s Eating Contest

Nathan’s serves up thousands of hot dogs and $20,000 in prize money.

Hot Dog Maven George Shea on Chestnut Comeback and Investor Interest

George Shea runs a real estate PR firm and Major League Eating.

Featured Today

Geoffrey Esper Can’t Catch a Break at Nathan’s Hot Dog Eating Contest

“Hot dogs is not one of my favorite competitions of the year.”
June 29, 2025

The Battle Over Wimbledon’s Ambitious Expansion Plan

A classic NIMBY standoff on one of the most hallowed grounds in sports.
Seattle Rough & Tumble
June 28, 2025

Women’s Sports Bars Are on the Rise. Survival Isn’t Guaranteed

Some women’s sports bars are cashing in. Others are clawing for funding.
June 27, 2025

Shitposters Have Taken the Reins of Pro Sports’ Official Voices

Meet the social media pros turning sports teams into internet trolls.
James Harden

Adidas Posts Big Profits in First Quarter Without Yeezy

Profits and sales are up after selling off remaining Yeezys last year.
Oracle Park
March 18, 2025

S.F. Giants Selling Stake to Private Equity to Pay for Facility Upgrades

The team said the cash would not be used to grow payroll.
March 20, 2025

Nike Struggles Continue, but Signs of Turnaround Appear

The embattled company beats tepid expectations in both revenue and earnings.
Sponsored

Hottest Matchups Following NFL Schedule Release

The NFL released the 2025 regular-season schedule, and anticipation is already building in the ticket marketplace with four months to go.
Aug 11, 2024; Paris, France; Medals are carried out on Louis Vuitton trays after the women's volleyball gold medal match during the Paris 2024 Olympic Summer Games at South Paris Arena
February 16, 2025

LVMH’s New Push: World’s Most Powerful Luxury Group Is Coming for Sports

LVMH is making long-term deals—and they’re not done.
February 14, 2025

DraftKings Turns First Full-Year Profit, Stock Up 47% in 2025

The company’s sports betting business continues to grow despite headwinds.
Billie Jean King
February 13, 2025

Billie Jean King: ‘Billionaires, Not Millionaires’ Are Fueling Women’s Sports Boom

Billie Jean King wants more women involved in team ownership, too.
February 5, 2025

Under Armour’s Desired Turnaround Sees Sparks With Q3 Earnings Beat

The 2010s darling has been struggling to find the right formula.