How did a fresh-faced Irish superstar become the lightning rod of the moment in pro golf?
This weekend’s rowdy, raucous Ryder Cup soap opera was the Rory McIlroy show. The single biggest media story this weekend was the verbal abuse hurled by New York fans at McIlroy and other European players. The biggest media story since has been McIlroy’s public response. Especially since the five-time major champion gave as good as he got with drunken fans.
Either way, McIlroy is the x-factor. When did the eager-to-please kid with the floppy head of curls become a cartoon villain for some golf fans?
Scottie Scheffler is golf’s best player. But he’s admittedly bland, mechanical. McIlroy’s the opposite. He’s opinionated, mercurial, unpredictable. The 36-year-old superstar doesn’t care whether you like him.
As evidenced during the height of the PGA Tour vs. LIV Golf rhetoric and now at the Ryder Cup, McIlroy’s become the loudest voice in golf. As Tiger Woods fades away, the 2025 Masters champion is the most vital voice, too.
After Team Europe’s victory, a high-handed McIlroy warned about the “unacceptable and abusive behavior” from fans at Bethpage Black Golf Course. “I don’t think we should ever accept that in golf. I think golf should be held to a higher standard than what was seen out there this week,” he said.
Good point. No athletes should face the type of abuse hurled by those yahoos this weekend. As Front Office Sports’s David Rumsey wrote, the PGA of America still has to explain how it let this year’s Ryder Cup spin out of control, both on and off the course.
But McIlroy was no choir boy, either, at Bethpage. As early as Friday, the fighting Irishman was bluntly telling hecklers to “shut the fuck up” in a video that quickly went viral. At another point, TV cameras captured McIlroy gleefully pointing his finger at the crowd—and hurling f-bombs, as well as swiftly directing security to throw out a fan who called him a slur. Did McIlroy arrive at Bethpage with a chip on his shoulder? Maybe so. Even Golf.com asked whether he was a hypocrite for his criticism of fans.
Paul Azinger, the former U.S. Ryder Cup captain, admires McIlroy. He credits the European superstar for turning down $500 million from rival LIV to stick with the American PGA Tour. But McIlroy wants it both ways, according to the Zinger.
“After it’s over, he is saying I think golf should be held to a higher standard of decorum. … But in the meantime he says, ‘Eff you, eff you, eff you,’ in full voice for the world to see. He turns around and says to the guy, ‘Shut the eff up.’ The guy in the media asks him today, ‘How did that feel, Rory, to tell the guy to shut the eff up, and then hit it to two feet?’ And he said, ‘It felt pretty effin’ good,’” the former NBC analyst told Drew Stoltz on the Subpar podcast.
“And I’m like, ‘Which is it, Rory?’ Is it that golf is held to a higher standard? Or are you just going to ‘eff you’ the fans and act like that’s O.K.?’ I love Rory. You know that. But you can’t say that. You can’t say the fans need to behave better and then, in the meantime, lay them to waste. You can’t do both. You’ve got to be one or the other. You can’t do both.”
On the other hand, the outspoken Brandel Chamblee believes McIlroy handled himself with class this weekend. The superstar put up with the abuse at first, the Golf Channel analyst said on his Favorite Chamblee podcast. But when hecklers hit McIlroy with homophobic slurs and mocking innuendos about his relationship with CBS announcer Amanda Balionis, and even threw a drink on his wife, Erica Stoll, he hit a “boiling point,” according to Chamblee. “They were hurling insults at Rory’s wife. She never brought it up to anybody like she was aggrieved or anything, which all class to her, all credit to her,” Chamblee said.
Ever since McIlroy won the 2011 U.S. Open at the precocious age of 22, he’s received fawning media coverage. But that’s not enough. Remember McIlroy bluntly reminding golf press at The Masters this year that he and other players are not obligated to speak to them after a round. If the press doesn’t like it, they can lump it.
Legends like Jack Nicklaus would beg to differ with his approach to the media. But it’s McIlroy’s time now, and he’s doing it his way.
His way also included making himself the defender of the PGA Tour, and that won him a lot of favor with veterans like Azinger, who despite his criticism of McIlroy’s Ryder Cup antics, emphasized: “I love Rory, because Rory stayed and fought for our tour.”
