• Loading stock data...
Friday, August 8, 2025
Tuned In returns to NYC on September 16. Hear from the biggest names in sports media. Click here to get your spot
Law

How ‘Punt God’ Matt Araiza Avoided Scrutiny For Months

  • Sources tell FOS there was nothing in Araiza’s pre-draft report that hinted at sexual assault allegations.
  • Araiza and two of his SDSU football teammates were accused of rape in a lawsuit filed last week.
Matt Araiza
Trevor Ruszkowski/USA TODAY Sports

Matt Araiza was picked by many NFL Draft prognosticators to be the first punter taken. 

The San Diego State product who earned the name “Punt God” was ultimately the third punter selected as the Buffalo Bills nabbed Araiza in the sixth round with the 180th overall pick.

While it was reported two teams had knowledge of something amiss in Araiza’s background, sources tell Front Office Sports that there was nothing flagged in the pre-draft info compiled by the NFL and distributed to teams. 

It stands to reason the Bills and other teams in need of a punter didn’t grasp the allegations Araiza faced, which were splayed out in Thursday’s lawsuit that alleged Araiza and two of his San Diego State football teammates were complicit in gang rape of an underaged high school girl last October.

The NFL as a whole has increased scrutiny of potential draft picks, especially when it comes to red flags on social media accounts that are traced back to prospects’ times in high school. Thorough background checks and interviews — especially of players expected to go in the early rounds — have led teams to make more informed decisions in the draft process. 

Without criminal charges, it’s often left to coaches — like SDSU head coach Brady Hoke, who walked out of an interview on Monday when asked about the rape allegations — to inform NFL teams about issues related to prospects. 

It’s not known if Araiza was confronted with anything in his background at the NFL Combine in February, where interested teams ask questions in private. The Bills apparently became enamored with Araiza at the Combine where he punted one ball in warmups 80 yards. 

The Bills, however, had some information before they tapped Araiza as their starting punter on Aug. 22. 

Near the start of training camp in July, Dan Gilleon, the attorney for the accuser, informed the Bills’ team attorney about the alleged incident. 

Araiza’s family said in a statement on Monday that “there are multiple witness reports to deny the claims that are made against” their son. 

“The legal system is designed to find the facts and make decisions,” the family said. “They should be allowed to do that.”

Even though the team said in a statement Thursday that it “conducted a thorough examination of this matter,” neither Gilleon nor any of his investigators ever spoke to the Bills again, a representative for the firm told FOS. 

This wasn’t April, when details of the case were known to few people. Gilleon wasn’t even representing the accuser yet, and information on the San Diego police investigation — which just recently got turned over to prosecutors — was closely guarded. 

Since the allegations occurred when Araiza was in his final year at SDSU, the league couldn’t take action under the personal conduct policy, the one that led to the 11-game suspension of Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson. 

That left the investigation up to the Bills. 

Gilleon said he rebuffed outreach by Araiza’s attorney about a settlement that could have kept the allegations private and, potentially, prevented charges ever being filed.  

A settlement isn’t sinister and isn’t technically a cover-up. But there were teams many years ago who occasionally worked to help players avoid arrest for incidents like one described by a former team security official. 

“The player punched him [at a bar]. He roughed him up pretty good,” the former security official said. “I got the tapes from the club that night. We heard another thing about it.”

The two former security officials told FOS that’s not the way the teams or the league operate now — and not just because we are in the age of smartphones and digital surveillance that’s often backed up to the cloud. 

“There were a small number of teams that did that kind of thing,” another security official said. “You send a player a message that basically says, ‘Everything will be taken care of.’ All you’re doing is enabling and it’s only going to get worse.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Etienne

A ‘College Football RedZone’ Is an ESPN Gold Mine—in Theory

The network would have to strike new deals with its rivals.

Smelling Salts Not Banned in the NFL, but Teams Can’t Hand Them..

Teams are banned from supplying smelling salts to their players.

More RedZones? 10 Burning Questions With ESPN’s Pitaro and NFL’s Schroeder

The execs behind the landmark ESPN-NFL deal sat down with FOS.

After Draft-Day Snub and Drama, Sanders to Start Preseason Opener

Multiple injuries mean Sanders gets the nod for the opening preseason game.

Featured Today

Inked Under Anesthesia: Athletes Getting $50,000 Tattoos

High-end studios, elite artist teams, and hours under anesthesia.
Coco Gauff at New York Liberty
August 2, 2025

How the New York Liberty Became the Hottest Ticket in Town

Once banished to the burbs, the Libs are now Brooklyn’s marquee attraction.
Las Vegas sign
July 29, 2025

College Sports Embracing Vegas After Years of Cold Shoulder

The Big Ten became the latest newcomer to Sin City.
2000, Jupiter, FL, USA; FILE PHOTO; Montreal Expos pitcher Hideki Irabu in action on the mound against the New York Mets at Roger Dean Stadium during Spring Training
July 28, 2025

Dead Sports Franchises Are Alive and Well on Twitter

The Expos, Sonics, and Whalers have active social media accounts.
WNBA

Crypto Group Says It’s Behind WNBA Dildo Epidemic

The group backs a memecoin that launched last week.
Josh Donaldson
August 5, 2025

Josh Donaldson Settles With Mold Landlord for $729K

Donaldson vacated the Greenwich, Ct., mansion shortly after moving in.
A general view as athletes compete in the women’s 10,000m final during the Paris 2024 Olympic Summer Games at Stade de France in Saint-Deanis, France, Friday, Aug. 9, 2024.
August 5, 2025

Trump Order Leads to Visa Ban for Trans Athletes in Women’s Sports

“Men do not belong in women’s sports,” a USCIS spokesperson said.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
Feb 20, 2011; Calgary, AB, Canada; Canadian hockey fans wave a flag and display a banner before the Heritage Classic between the Montreal Canadiens and the Calgary Flames at McMahon Stadium. The Flames beat the Canadiens 4-0
August 1, 2025

Where Does Hockey Go After the Hockey Canada Verdict?

After the sexual assault trial, hockey is split over the path forward.
Troy Taylor
July 31, 2025

Ex-Stanford Coach Troy Taylor Sues ESPN for Defamation

Taylor was fired after a pair of 3–9 seasons.
Gilbert Arenas
July 31, 2025

Gilbert Arenas Charged With Running Illegal Poker Operation With ‘Organized Crime Figure’

The former NBA player allegedly ran a poker club from his house.
Marcus Morris
July 30, 2025

Marcus Morris Denies Fraud, Blames Mixup for $260K Casino Debt Arrest

Morris made roughly $107 million across 13 NBA seasons.