Thursday, November 19, 2026

House v. NCAA Objections Highlight Three Major Concerns

The settlement has been hailed as a step in the right direction. But that doesn’t mean everyone is satisfied.

Nov 23, 2024; Kansas City, Missouri, USA; Colorado linebacker LaVonta Bentley (20) during gets set at his position during the 1st quarter between the Kansas Jayhawks and the Colorado Buffaloes at GEHA Field at Arrowhead Stadium.
Nick Tre. Smith-Imagn Images

Want more from Front Office Sports
in your search results?

Add Front Office Sports on Google

The House v. NCAA settlement proposal—which would award athletes back-damages for missing out on NIL (name, image, and likeness) profits and set up a revenue-sharing system—has been hailed as a step in the right direction for college sports’ next era. But not everyone is happy with its terms.

As part of the settlement approval process, dozens of current and former Division I athletes, parents, and other stakeholders have filed objections before the Jan. 31 deadline. The three biggest concerns, according to court documents reviewed by Front Office Sports: roster limits, gender equity, and potential antitrust violations. 

“This is a class of hundreds of thousands of athletes,” plaintiff attorney Jeffrey Kessler tells Front Office Sports. “There are always going to be a tiny percentage of objectors. But the court’s task is to decide: Is this in the overall best interest of the class?” 

On April 7, Northern District of California judge Claudia Wilken will consider the objections and hear oral arguments during a “Fairness Hearing,” after which she’ll rule on whether to give the settlement the final stamp of approval.

Kessler says that more than 40,000 claims have already been filed in the case. He’s confident the settlement will ultimately be approved—despite the three main concerns.

Roster Limits

The majority of objections centered on what could be considered an “unintended consequence” of the settlement. One of the settlement’s terms would eliminate the NCAA’s limits on scholarships—but, in turn, would allow the governing body to impose overall roster limits. 

Current and former athletes, as well as their parents, have written to Judge Wilken saying the NCAA’s imposed roster limits will cause players to lose walk-on or partial scholarship spots across many sports. There is evidence that, across the country, schools have already begun revoking offers to prospective recruits in anticipation of these new roster limits, according to a previous Yahoo Sports report. 

“Football teams like mine, which often carry more than 105 players, will have no choice but to ask dozens of student-athletes to leave,” Colorado walk-on football player Camden Dempsey wrote in an objection letter filed Jan. 1 that was co-signed by 43 other athletes from the Big 12. “At Colorado, this will mean cutting players who have, for years, shown up for early morning workouts, endured the grind of practice, and given everything to the team. This issue extends across all sports and institutions, putting thousands of student-athletes in jeopardy. … Walk-ons who are cut also will face real, concrete, and immediate, financial damages as many walk-ons have worked to arrange NIL deals and create businesses.” 

Dempsey, for his part, suggested a “grandfathering provision” to exempt current athletes from losing their roster spots if House is approved. But others have asked to abandon roster limits altogether.

In response to this concern, Kessler clarifies the settlement doesn’t require or put in place any specific roster limits—it simply allows the NCAA to create them. “If the NCAA doesn’t want to have roster limits, it is totally free not to have roster limits,” he says, adding that the settlement doesn’t protect the NCAA from future litigation over roster limits, either.

Gender Equity

The formula for distributing $2.8 billion in back-damages is based on exposure and media value. So it’s no surprise that athletes from the two “revenue-earning” sports—football and men’s basketball—will receive significantly more compensation than everyone else. 

Several groups of women’s sports athletes have challenged the settlement, pointing out gender inequities in the damages and revenue-sharing. “Class Counsel proclaim they have negotiated a ‘revolutionary settlement agreement’ that will ‘reshape the economic landscape of college sports’ and benefit future college athletes,’” seven female rowers wrote in an objection filed before the preliminary approval hearing in September. “True – but only for male football and basketball players.”

During that hearing, plaintiff lawyers addressed this issue, noting the damages were based on the “real world”—which was, unfortunately, riddled with gender inequities that have been well documented. Issues with the NCAA’s gender equity failures should be the subject of separate litigation, they said.

Kessler notes he supports Title IX but reiterates: “This is an antitrust case—it cannot resolve the gender equity issues.” But he reiterates that if the Department of Education requires schools to share revenue equitably among women’s and men’s sports athletes, then they’ll have to do so.

New Antitrust Issues

While the settlement sets up a revenue-sharing formula for athletes, it also imposes new restrictions. For example, it imposes a revenue-sharing cap of $20.5 million per school—a number that will increase incrementally over the next 10 years.

Just days before President Donald Trump took office, the Biden Administration’s U.S. Department of Justice filed a statement of interest asking Judge Wilken to block the settlement because it allows for a cap on revenue-sharing. In a scathing, 11-page document, the DOJ said the revenue-sharing agreement “still calls for an artificial price cap on what free market competition may otherwise yield.” 

The statement of interest is not a formal objection, given the DOJ does not qualify as a plaintiff. And despite the weight the federal justice department can hold in court, Kessler doesn’t believe it will be enough to sway Wilken’s opinion. Kessler also notes the DOJ is free to sue the NCAA itself in the future if it so chooses.

“It is ironic for the DOJ to file these comments,” Kessler says. “For 50 years, it could have challenged the NCAA restrictions. … And it did nothing.”

Download the FOS App

The business of sports, in your pocket.

QR code to download the app

Scan the QR code to get the app now.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

The Red Rising Fireside Chat event on November 16, 2026 at CrossCountry Mortgage Campus.

How ‘Red Rising’ Swept Through the Browns Clubhouse

A dystopian book series has “instantly bonded” many Browns players and staffers.
Rob Manfred

Manfred Draws Hard Line on Salary Cap: MLB ‘Will Not Compromise’

An already bitter labor divide has grown even more fractious.
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), left, alongside Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT), as former special counsel Jack Smith appears before the Senate Judiciary Committee for a second time as Republicans question his investigation into Trump on Sept. 29, 2026.

Cruz Negotiates With Dems in Last-Chance Effort to Save PCSA

The bill garnered a bipartisan vote in the Senate.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

11/19/26 – Which ’24 QBs Will Get Paid?, Skubal to the Mets?, NFL’s Hottest & Coldest Tickets

0:00

Featured Today

Soccer Football - Premier League - Aston Villa v Brentford - Villa Park, Birmingham, Britain - October 10, 2026 Aston Villa's Boubacar Kamara applauds fans after the match

English Soccer Still Inundated by Gambling Ads Despite Jersey Ban

The ban on front-of-shirt gambling ads looks strict, but it’s largely cosmetic.
West Wind Mahjong
November 11, 2026

Mahjong Mania Has Come for College Sports

Bespoke retailers are cashing in with officially licensed mahjong sets.
November 6, 2026

Can MLS Capitalize on Son-Mania?

Korea and Tottenham fans alike have flocked to LAFC’s away matches.
Pickering High School North
November 4, 2026

High School Athletic Directors Say They’re Running ‘Mini Colleges’

ADs are managing a growing list of demands from athletes and parents.
October 30, 2026

How Injuries Hit Pro Marathoners in the Wallet

Staying healthy can get expensive—quickly.
Jon Rothstein CBS Sports

Jon Rothstein Doesn’t Blame NIL for College Basketball’s Empty Seats

The CBS Sports personality also discussed his $15K bar tab in Lincoln.
Grand Valley State hosts Ferris State in the Anchor-Bone Classic on Saturday, Oct. 17, at Lubbers Stadium in Allendale.
First at FOS
November 17, 2026

‘Big Noon Kickoff’ and ‘College GameDay’ Both Courted Ferris State

The D-II school is attracting major networks amid a record-breaking season.
Oct 10, 2025; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Boston Celtics forward R.J. Luis Jr. (12) loses control of the ball against Toronto Raptors guard Chucky Hepburn (24) and forward Jonathan Mogbo (2) in the second half at Scotiabank Arena
November 17, 2026

LSU Rosters Ex-NBA Player After Protracted NCAA Eligibility Saga

RJ Luis Jr. could suit up for LSU as soon as Wednesday.
Sponsored

Tracy McGrady Is Building A Basketball Ecosystem

The NBA legend talks turning his playing career into a portfolio of sports investments.
November 16, 2026

Philip Rivers Will Be Among Lowest-Paid Coaches in Power 4

Rivers will earn $3.25 million in his first season.
Sep 5, 2026; Eugene, Oregon, USA; Boise State Broncos tight end Matt Wagner (88) leaps over Oregon Ducks defensive back Davon Benjamin (5) on a pass play during the second half at Autzen Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Troy Wayrynen-Imagn Images
November 16, 2026

Group of 6 Leaders Fear Scheduling Squeeze in 24-Team CFP Era

The G6 is guaranteed one spot each season in the 24-team field.
November 16, 2026

MiLaysia Fulwiley Denies Striking Officer With Her Car After Arrest

Fulwiley is projected to be a lottery pick in the 2027 draft. 
November 15, 2026

LSU’s Playoff Hopes Gone in First Year of $91M Kiffin Era

Kiffin now has four losses in his first season.