• Loading stock data...
Tuesday, November 5, 2024
The Best Employers in Sports survey is open through Nov. 6 Learn More

‘Sour Grapes’: Lawyers Battle Over Landmark Settlement to Pay College Athletes

  • Attorneys from the O’Bannon v. NCAA case challenged the House settlement terms with a formal objection.
  • The filing, which seven current and former athletes signed, says the terms range from unfair to flat-out illegal. 
Former Iowa basketball player Jordan Bohannon
Andrew Wevers-Imagn Images

The landmark House v. NCAA settlement—already arguably on the rocks—is facing yet another objection.

This time, it’s from the lawyers who won the O’Bannon v. NCAA case that paved the way for college athletes to be paid for their name, image and likeness.

On Thursday, a group of seven current and former athletes represented by attorney Michael Hausfeld filed an objection arguing that the terms in the proposed House settlement range from unfair to flat-out illegal. 

Those terms include $2.8 billion in damage payments to current and former college athletes, a revenue-sharing model where schools would pay athletes directly, and new restrictions on NIL collectives.

Among the athletes are Iowa men’s basketball player Jordan Bohannon, known for advocating for NIL rights during his time as a player, and former Vanderbilt and Georgetown sprinter Kaira Brown, another outspoken athletes’ rights advocate.

House plaintiff lawyers Steve Berman and Jeff Kessler dismissed the objections in comments Thursday to The Athletic. “We have negotiated an almost $3 billion settlement for college athletes. The Hausfeld firm never obtained anything for damages class in the case brought against the NCAA,” Kessler said. Berman called it “sour grapes,” noting he and Kessler were the attorneys on NCAA v. Alston, a case over athlete educational benefits that, while not about NIL directly, also helped pave the way for the current era. 

The new objection echoes several already raised in written objections, as well as concerns voiced by Northern District of California Judge Claudia Wilken during a Sept. 5 hearing. 

It argues the damage payments for athletes who weren’t allowed to participate in NIL before 2021, which amount to about $2.8 billion, are too low. It also suggests that the payment structure, highly controversial among non-power conference commissioners and schools, is “unfair to smaller member institutions.”

The objection takes issue with the revenue-sharing proposed in the injunctive relief portion of the settlement, which would allow schools to share revenue with players up to only about 22% of revenue. The revenue-sharing cap is arbitrary and much lower than the percentage that pro athletes receive—around 50% in the collective bargaining agreements in major U.S. men’s leagues—the objection says, and could limit the money athletes earn in the future. It binds future athletes to an agreement in which they not only have no say, but also would be “worse off.” (Berman and Kessler have argued athlete compensation would equal 50% when the House settlement revenue-sharing deal is added to scholarships and other existing benefits.)

The objection also says the restriction on NIL deals is illegal. The restriction would allow a third party to prohibit NIL collective and booster deals over $600 if they appear to be “pay-for-play” deals rather than “fair-market value.” Judge Wilken took issue with this as well, but the NCAA’s lawyer, Rakesh Kilaru, said the governing body likely wouldn’t agree to a settlement without it.

Finally, the objection points out the NCAA wants to use the settlement to get a federal law passed that would block college athletes from being legally declared employees. The NCAA, for its part, has said multiple times that that’s exactly what it intends to do with the settlement.

The parties filed an amended complaint with limited changes last week. Wilken will decide on whether to grant preliminary approval to the amended settlement, or whether the parties should prepare for a trial that would likely begin early in 2025.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

New Era, New Chaos? New CFP Team Rankings Explained

The new College Football Playoff system’s complexities might confuse some college football fans.

Super Bowl Ads Sell Out Three Months Early, at Record Price

Ad units are believed to be selling at more than $7 million per 30 seconds.
Tony Hinchcliffe at Donald Trump rally.

Sports Betting Companies Holding Comic at Arm’s Length After Trump Rally

Hinchcliffe drew criticism over his comments at a rally for Trump.
Apr 1, 2024; Portland, OR, USA; USC Trojans guard JuJu Watkins (12) drives to the basket during the second half against UConn Huskies guard Paige Bueckers (5) in the finals of the Portland Regional of the NCAA Tournament at the Moda Center.

Women’s College Basketball Begins Its Star-Studded Post–Caitlin Clark Era

Women outdrew the men in the championship with 18.9 million viewers.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Surprising Start to MLB’s Offseason

0:00

Featured Today

Vanderbilt Commodores fans head to the south end zone as the goal post is taken down by exuberant fans after beating No. 1 Alabama 40-35 at Vanderbilt Stadium in Nashville, Tenn., Saturday, Oct. 5, 2024.
opinion

Something New in College Football This Year: Parity

Upsets, surprises. CFB is more fun on the field than the NFL.
Sep 28, 2024; Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA; GOP Presidential candidate Donald Trump waves flanked by former Georgia Bulldogs player Herschel Walker, recording art Kid Rock, professional golfer John Daily, Alabama senators Tommy Tuberville (R) and Katie Britt (R) during the second half of the game between the Alabama Crimson Tide and the Georgia Bulldogs at Bryant-Denny Stadium.
November 1, 2024

Mission Swing State: College Football’s Political Advertising Battle

Trump, Harris, and the PACs that support them are utilizing the sport.
October 31, 2024

The Untapped Revenue ‘Powder Keg’ of Women’s NFL Fandom

There’s a “boatload” of money at stake for brands and the league.
Donald Trump holding a basketball in the White House
October 30, 2024

Mavericks Owner’s $100 Million Trump Donation Dwarfs All Other Sports Owner Political Giving

Dr. Miriam Adelson is one of the most powerful donors in U.S. politics.
Oct 4, 2024; Durham, NC, USA; Duke Blue Devils guard Cooper Flagg (2) is introduced to the fans during Countdown to Craziness at Cameron Indoor Stadium.

All Eyes on Cooper Flagg As College Basketball Tips Off

He makes his NCAA debut with Duke on Monday.
Eastern New Mexico forward Jose Murillo (33) passes the ball between Grand Canyon University forward Sammie Yeanay (23) and guard Makaih Williams (2) during an exhibition game at Global Credit Union Arena in Phoenix on Oct. 29, 2024.
November 1, 2024

Grand Canyon University to Join Mountain West in 2026

The Mountain West has added three new schools after the Pac-12 poached five from the conference.
Donald Trump
November 4, 2024

ESPN Will Drop First 12-Team CFP Rankings in Heart of Election Night

The network traditionally hasn’t shied away from going up against election coverage.
Sponsored

World Series Delivers High-Demand Marquee Matchup

The hype around the World Series matchup drove ticket prices to record levels—but the Dodgers’ dominance quickly quieted the fervor.
November 1, 2024

Olympic Sport College Coaches Hire Lobbyists Amid NCAA Upheaval

The NCAA and power conferences have spent millions on an effort to preserve amateurism.
The Fox Big Noon Kickoff crew broadcasts from the endzone prior to the NCAA football game between the Ohio State Buckeyes and the Nebraska Cornhuskers at Ohio Stadium in Columbus on Saturday, Oct. 26, 2024.
October 31, 2024

ESPN-Fox Pregame Battle in Focus at Ohio State–Penn State

Fox has the game broadcast at noon ET.
October 28, 2024

College Football Playoff Expansion Already Heating Up Off-Field Drama

ESPN’s and Fox’s rival pregame shows will broadcast from the same campus.
Oct 19, 2024; Gainesville, Florida, USA; Florida Gators quarterback DJ Lagway (2) shakes hands while entering the locker room after a game against the Kentucky Wildcats at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium.
October 28, 2024

NIL Director Is the Trendy New Job in College Sports. But the Role Is Chaos

Athletic departments nationwide are hiring for what’s become their most important position.