• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 10, 2024
The Best Employers in Sports survey is now open! Take the survey

Federal Judge to Hear Arguments Over Athlete Pay Settlement Proposal

  • The hearing, set for Thursday afternoon, is the first major step in the House v. NCAA settlement process.
  • The proposal would facilitate athlete revenue-sharing for the first time in college sports history but also would impose new compensation restrictions.
? speaks during a press conference celebrating the 25 year anniversary of the NCAA moving its national office to Indianapolis on Tuesday, Aug. 13, 2024, at the NCAA Headquarters in Indianapolis.
Michelle Pemberton/IndyStar / USA TODAY NETWORK

On Thursday afternoon, Northern District of California Judge Claudia Wilken will hold a hearing for preliminary approval of the House v. NCAA settlement—a potentially landmark agreement that would facilitate revenue-sharing between schools and college athletes for the first time in history. 

The hearing, which will begin at 5:30 p.m. ET, is the first major step in a months-long process to approve the proposal, which plaintiff lawyers submitted to the court in July

The case, first filed in 2020, argues athletes who didn’t get to earn name, image, and likeness (NIL) income before 2021 deserve back-pay; and, that going forward, the definition of NIL should expand to include things like broadcast media contracts. The case threatened to bankrupt the NCAA and Power 5 conferences, who are the six named defendants—so they struck an agreement with plaintiffs, led by attorneys Jeffrey Kessler and Steve Berman.

The 300-page settlement proposal, which would also end litigation in the Hubbard v. NCAA and Carter v. NCAA antitrust cases, would allow for $2.8 billion in back damages to multiple types of plaintiff classes—mostly Division I football and basketball players, but also Olympic sports athletes. It would also allow schools to share up to a certain percentage of revenue (starting at around $22 million) with players each year.

But the fine print of the agreement also creates restrictions and caveats on future athlete earnings, including a revenue-sharing cap and the ability for a third party to prevent NIL deals over $600. Also as part of the agreement, plaintiff lawyers and named plaintiffs would be obligated to lobby in Congress in favor of turning the settlement into a federal law.

The settlement hearing itself will feature lawyers representing both the athletes and the NCAA and power conferences, all of whom will be arguing why Judge Wilken should allow the proposal to enter its next phase in the approval process. 

However, there will also be presentations by outside counsel representing several groups of athletes who have raised objections to the proposal. They include lawyers representing athletes already suing the NCAA for similar alleged antitrust violations, and lawyers representing a group of female athletes who claim that the settlement terms unfairly disadvantage women’s sports athletes. (An objection by lawyers for Ivy League athletes suing the conference over its lack of athletic scholarships was withdrawn after House plaintiff lawyers made it clear that their case won’t be folded into the settlement.)

Judge Wilken could make a ruling on whether to preliminarily approve the settlement immediately from the bench, according to legal experts. Or, she could wait to issue a ruling in writing in the days or weeks following the hearing. 

If Wilken gives her blessing, a timeline will be set in motion for the next stages of settlement approval. At or around Oct. 1, lawyers will begin sending out information to members of the plaintiff class about the settlement. Athletes who wish to file a formal objection to the settlement, or who wish to opt out of the settlement altogether, will have a period of a little more than three months to notify the court. (It’s at this point that athletes represented by the National College Players Association, or by another group of attorneys who filed an amicus brief against the settlement, may submit their grievances.) Unless objections or opt-outs are strong enough to halt the settlement, a final hearing to approve it could be held in the winter of 2025.

If Wilken doesn’t grant preliminary approval Thursday, however, the plaintiff lawyers and defendants will have to go back to the drawing board—either rejiggering parts of the settlement or scrapping it entirely.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Twins Hit the Market: Pohlad Family Looks to End Four-Decade Ownership

The MLB club is considering a sale after four decades of Pohlad family ownership.

Cam Newton Joins First Take, Where His Opinions Should Fit Right in

ESPN has hired the 2015 NFL MVP as a contributor to First Take.
Sep 13, 2024; New York, New York, USA; United States men's national team head coach Mauricio Pochettino poses for a photo with chief executive officer and secretary general JT Batson, sporting director Matt Crocker, president Cindy Parlow Cone, and MLS commissioner Don Garber after a press conference introducing him as the new head coach for the United States men's national team at Warner Bros. Discovery Hudson Center.

U.S. Soccer, Flush With Cash, Lays Off Dozens

The nonprofit federation is expecting nine figures in revenue this fiscal year.
Nike

Nike Has Lost Some Mojo. But Not Its Market Share

Nike is in recovery mode but still enjoys a dominant slice of the market.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Patriots Hit Rock Bottom; WNBA Finals Begin

0:00

Featured Today

Duante' Abercrombie News Ch.4 interview

Tennessee State’s Ambitious Plan to Launch an HBCU Hockey Program

TSU has big plans, but the university is facing an existential dilemma.
October 8, 2024

Ryan Smith Sees Salt Lake City As Next Vegas-Like Sports Town

Utah Hockey Club’s owner says all the pieces are falling into place.
October 8, 2024

How the WWE’s Farm Circuit Became a Primetime Draw

NXT produces generational talent—and it occupies a new prime-time network slot.
A DraftKings sign
October 7, 2024

A DraftKings Exec Left for Fanatics. Then the Bitter Legal Battle Began

Mike Hermalyn has been sidelined at Fanatics for nine months now.

Why CFB Super-League Proposals Are Likely Doomed

Could a college football super league work one day in the future?
Sep 6, 2024; Dallas, Texas, USA; Big 12 Commissioner Brett Yormark before the game between the Southern Methodist Mustangs and the Brigham Young Cougars at Gerald J. Ford Stadium.
October 8, 2024

Big 12’s Brett Yormark Doesn’t ‘Wake Up Thinking’ About SEC, Big Ten

Big 12’s commissioner says he isn’t concerned about reports of a Big Ten–SEC scheduling alliance.
October 9, 2024

Duke Men’s Basketball GM Explains How She’d Avoid UNLV NIL Disaster

Rachel Baker was one of the first hires as a college GM.
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
October 7, 2024

Vandy Trying to Cash In on Upset

Vanderbilt quarterback Diego Pavia is looking for new NIL deals.
The NCAA logo on a football field
October 7, 2024

Landmark House Settlement to Pay College Athletes Gets Preliminary Approval From Judge

The deal in House v. NCAA previously appeared to be in jeopardy.
October 6, 2024

Vandy, Arkansas Fined After Upsets

The two schools’ fanbases ran onto the fields after games ended.
OSU QB Terrelle Pryor
October 4, 2024

Terrelle Pryor Sues Ohio State As Group of Athletes Seeking NIL Back-Pay Grows

Reggie Bush, Michigan players, and NC State’s basketball team sued this year.