• Loading stock data...
Thursday, September 18, 2025

Federal Judge ‘Concerned’ with House v. NCAA Settlement Proposal

  • Judge Claudia Wilken said she is “quite concerned” about multiple aspects related to NIL and future litigation.
  • Attorneys agreed to set a three-week deadline to edit the proposal.
Sep 2, 2024; Tallahassee, Florida, USA; Florida State Seminoles linebacker Justin Cryer (28) reacts during the fourth quarter against the Boston College Eagles at Doak S. Campbell Stadium.
Melina Myers-USA TODAY Sports

In the words of Northern District of California Court Judge Claudia Wilken, it’s “back to the drawing board” on the potentially landmark House v. NCAA settlement proposal.

Wilken did not grant preliminary approval for the settlement during a virtual hearing on Thursday. Attorneys involved in the case agreed to set a three-week deadline to edit the proposal and resubmit it to the court.

Wilken raised concerns about major aspects of the proposal. She took issue with restrictions on NIL payments, asked tough questions about a revenue-sharing cap, and asked to add language to ensure that the settlement still allows for other antitrust lawsuits against the NCAA. Wilken offered to submit preliminary approval for one of the three cases negotiated in the settlement proposal, called Hubbard v. NCAA, while the parties renegotiate some of the House v. NCAA aspect of the deal. The NCAA’s attorney, Rakesh Kilaru, said the governing body would not agree to that.

There was even talk of preparing for a trial date if the parties couldn’t agree to certain changes to the settlement.

Wilken’s comments, in several cases, reflected points raised by objecting lawyers including Steven Molo, who represented a group of female athletes arguing that women’s sports athletes should get more in the settlement, and Garrett Broshuis, representing athletes in the ongoing Fontenot v. NCAA case. She raised other issues in line with the opinion of the National College Players Association, which said it intends to put together a group of athlete objectors.

The case, first filed in 2020, argues athletes should receive back-pay for several years before the NCAA changed its NIL (name, image, and likeness) rules, as well as expand the definition of NIL to include things like broadcast revenue. Defendants include the NCAA and Power 5 conferences.

The 300-page settlement proposal consolidates two other antitrust cases related to athlete compensation restrictions, Hubbard v. NCAA and Carter v. NCAA. The crux of the settlement says the NCAA and power conferences would pay $2.8 billion in back-damages to athletes who couldn’t benefit from NIL before 2021 (mostly football and men’s basketball players, but most of Division I if not all would be eligible for something). Schools would also be allowed to share up to a certain percentage of revenue with athletes, starting at around $22 million per year. Beyond these big-ticket items, the settlement sets up restrictions including a cap on revenue sharing, an approval process for any NIL deals over $600, and an obligation for plaintiff lawyers and class members to lobby in Congress to codify the settlement into law. 

Wilken said she was “quite concerned” about the NIL rules, which allow NIL deals over $600 to be blocked if they’re seen by a third party as above fair market value. “I’ve found that taking things away from people is usually not very popular,” says Wilken. She also noted that the rules may not be enforceable legally, given that the definition of the word “booster” didn’t make much sense to her.

Plaintiff lawyers suggested they would be in favor of amending this part of the proposal—but the NCAA would not be. Kilaru called these NIL restrictions essential. “Without it, I’m not sure there will be a settlement to submit,” he said. 

In response, Wilken said that the lawyers would just have to “go back to the drawing board.” She said attorneys need to come up with language surrounding NIL that is workable, enforceable, and fair.

Wilken also indicated that she has no intention of letting the NCAA off the hook for future challenges. Some of her requests seemed to be more well-received than others.

She said she was “quite concerned” about who would represent future athletes in potential lawsuits challenging the revenue-sharing cap, or other areas of the settlement.

Wilken asked for the settlement to include language that several major lawsuits would be able to go forward even if the House case is settled: Johnson v. NCAA, a case arguing D-I athletes should be considered employees, as well as Choh v. Ivy League, a case arguing the Ivy League is illegally prohibiting athletic scholarships. “Maybe I’m being overly cautious,” joked Wilken, who has heard both the landmark O’Bannon and Alston cases. 

Additionally, Wilken asked for language to ensure that schools wouldn’t be protected from Title IX lawsuits in the future if they violate the gender equity statute in implementing the settlement terms, like revenue-sharing. 

The NCAA, for its part, hopes to convince Congress to create a law based on the settlement—one that prevents athlete employment status once and for all. But other organizations like Huma’s are already battling in court and in Congress. A group called Athletes.org put out a statement Wednesday saying that while it supports the settlement, athletes should be able to collectively bargain with schools in the future.

The settlement proposal has a long way to go before Congress can even consider it. “Based on [Wilken’s] comments today, we have to discuss whether we have a deal,” Kilaru said.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Sep 13, 2025; San Francisco, California, USA; Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Clayton Kershaw (22) delivers a pitch against the San Francisco Giants in the first inning at Oracle Park.

Dodgers Pitcher Clayton Kershaw Retiring After 18 Seasons

Kershaw is fourth all-time in career earnings for a pitcher.
Baseball

NCAA Settles With Volunteer Baseball Coaches for $49 Million

A similar suit brought by volunteer coaches of other sports remains open.
Adriunna Brown

Business Is Booming for WNBA’s Top Beauty Pros

A network of stylists is shaping how players look, feel, and perform.
Sep 13, 2025; Miami Gardens, Florida, USA; Miami Hurricanes running back Mark Fletcher Jr. (4) carries the football against South Florida Bulls cornerback Ben Knox (1) during the third quarter at Hard Rock Stadium.

NCAA Eliminates Spring Transfer Portal Window

The change is aimed at curbing the system of “unrestricted free agency.”

Featured Today

Premier Lacrosse League

‘The Circus Is Coming to Town’: Why Upstart Leagues Start on Tour

In their ambitious plans, a traveling schedule is only temporary.
PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA - APRIL 19: A detailed view of the MLB Debut patch on the jersey of Patrick Monteverde #44 of the Miami Marlins prior to game against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citizens Bank Park on April 19, 2025 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
September 13, 2025

The Tiny Jersey Patch at the Center of the MLB Rookie Card..

Autographed cards containing a piece of baseball history have upended the market.
September 11, 2025

Eagles-Chiefs Super Bowl Rematch Could Set More NFL Ratings Records

Fox will nationally televise Sunday afternoon’s matchup.
September 10, 2025

ESPN’s ‘MNF’ Ratings Up 8% As NFL Surges to Strong Start

ESPN posts its second-best Week 1 “Monday Night Football” audience.
Sep 13, 2025; Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA; Alabama Crimson Tide running back AK Dear (0) tries to outrun Wisconsin Badgers cornerback Ricardo Hallman (2) during the second half at Saban Field at Bryant-Denny Stadium.

Despite Vote Delay, SCORE Act Negotiations Continue on Capitol Hill

Political ad campaigns during college football Saturdays continue as well.
Sep 12, 2025; Pasadena, California, USA; UCLA Bruins quarterback Nico Iamaleava (9) looks to pass during the first quarter against the New Mexico Lobos at Rose Bowl.
September 15, 2025

UCLA-Tennessee QB Trade Has Been Painful So Far

Iamaleava abruptly left Tennessee for UCLA this past offseason.
Sep 12, 2025; Pasadena, California, USA; New Mexico Lobos quarterback Jack Layne (2) reacts after his team scored a touchdown during the fourth quarter against the UCLA Bruins at Rose Bowl.
September 15, 2025

UCLA Paid New Mexico $1.2 Million for Friday’s Loss: Payout Game Tracker

The Bruins weren’t the only Power-4 school to lose a buy game and fire their coach.
Sponsored

How World Series Champ Dexter Fowler Became a Premier League Team Owner

Dexter Fowler discusses navigating retirement and embracing new roles as an owner & investor.
September 14, 2025

College Football’s Costly Start for Virginia Tech, UCLA: Coaches Out

UCLA and Virginia Tech fire their coaches while Notre Dame slumps badly.
Mar 4, 2025; Washington, DC, USA; House Majority Leader Steve Scalise, R-La., speaks with Rep. Marjorie Taylor-Greene, R-Ga., ahead of President Trump’s address to a joint session of Congress at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, D.C., on March 4, 2025.
September 11, 2025

House Republicans Delay SCORE Act Vote Tentatively Planned for Next Week

They didn’t believe they had enough votes to pass the bill.
Jan 25, 2023; Langley, British Columbia, CAN; Highlights from the CHL Kubota Top Prospects game at the Langley Events Centre
September 10, 2025

NCAA Hockey Scouts Denied Passes for Crucial Recruiting League

The CHL won’t welcome scouts on passes: “It comes across as petty.”
Feb 17, 2024; Boise, Idaho, USA; Fresno State Bulldogs guard Jalen Weaver (5) during the first half against the Boise State Broncos at ExtraMile Arena.
September 10, 2025

NCAA Bans 3 Basketball Players for Violating Betting Rules Last Season

The former San Jose State and Fresno State players have lost eligibility.