• Loading stock data...
Thursday, August 28, 2025
Front Office Sports Honors winners are here! View the 2025 winners

At Least 250 Athletes Have Opted Out of the House v. NCAA Settlement

Fontenot v. NCAA, which was first filed in 2023, goes much further than the claims brought by House v. NCAA.

The NCAA logo on the field in the closing second of the Anderson University inaugural football game with St. Andrew's University on Spero Financial Field at Melvin and Dollie Younts Stadium at Anderson University in Anderson, S.C. Saturday, September 7, 2024. Anderson won 51-14.
Imagn Images

Hundreds of current and former college athletes have filed objections to various aspects of the House v. NCAA settlement, citing concerns about gender equity and antitrust, as well as protesting the settlement allowing for roster limits. 

And other college athletes have taken their grievances a step further.

More than 150 Division I athletes, from football and baseball to women’s basketball players, decided to opt out of the House settlement on Friday and join a separate ongoing lawsuit called Fontenot v. NCAA, plaintiff lawyers told FOS. 

Also on Friday, 67 athletes, led by former Mississippi State running back Kylin Hill, have opted out in order to file a new case against the NCAA and power conferences in the Northern District of California called Hill v. NCAA. On the same day, another lawsuit including 33 opt-outs led by Wyoming basketball player Dontaie Allen, Allen v. NCAA, was filed in the Eastern District of Kentucky. 

That means that at least 250 current and former athletes have decided to opt out of the settlement altogether. The goal: receive a higher payment than what the House v. NCAA settlement offers.

The House settlement would provide $2.8 billion in back-damages to athletes who couldn’t profit off NIL (name, image, and likeness) deals before 2021, as well as allow revenue-sharing between schools and players. But it includes other stipulations, like a cap on revenue-sharing, the imposition of roster limits, and the ability to block booster or collective-funded NIL deals that are considered “pay-for-play.”

It’s unclear how much this would impact the House settlement itself. The settlement claims are being offered to hundreds of thousands of athletes, and 40,000 have filed claims suggesting they would participate, plaintiff attorney Jeff Kessler told FOS last week.

If a certain number of athletes agree to opt out of the settlement, it could trigger an automatic rejection of the terms—but that number is redacted from public court documents. (A list of opt-outs is slated to be publicized on March 3.)

Fontenot v. NCAA, which was first filed in Colorado federal district court in 2023, goes much further than the claims brought by House v. NCAA. It argues that the NCAA and Power 5 conferences have illegally restricted all forms of athlete compensation beyond NIL deals, and that plaintiffs deserve damages for more than just lost NIL rights. The named plaintiff, Alex Fontenot, played football at Colorado between 2017-22. He was among the four other plaintiffs listed in an amended complaint filed in July, which also includes Sarah Fuller, a former Vanderbilt soccer player who became famous when she became the first female kicker in a Power 5 football game. 

The group of 150 athletes joining the lawsuit includes more than 40 All-Americans across various sports, and athletes who have played in the NFL, NBA, WNBA, and MLB, Fontenot v. NCAA plaintiff attorney Garrett Broshius confirmed to FOS.

The Allen v. NCAA case, which does not name any conferences as defendants, includes 33 D-I men’s basketball and football players and argues that the NCAA has illegally restricted multiple types of compensation, including NIL rights. Named plaintiff Dontaie Allen played basketball at Kentucky and Western Kentucky, and is currently at Wyoming. 

“One of the big drivers for us … was the way the non-Power 5 athletes were treated was completely not commensurate with the services they provided,” Allen v. NCAA plaintiff attorney Chris Macke tells FOS. “And I’m talking about guys that got to the Final Four, guys that got to the NCAA Finals, were everywhere, that were the most famous athletes in America. … Those guys should be compensated far beyond what they would be compensated [in House v. NCAA].” There were athletes who Macke is representing who wouldn’t even receive four-figure payments under the House settlement.

On the other hand, the new Hill v. NCAA case argues similar claims to the House v. NCAA. Kylin Hill is one of 67 plaintiffs, all of whom played Division I sports ranging from football to softball, before 2021. The case argues that players deserve back-damages for not receiving NIL payments before 2021 and that the definition of NIL should be expanded to include broadcast rights; it also asks for an injunction to stop the NCAA and conferences from restricting NIL in the future. 

Some of the language in the Hill complaint appears to be copied and pasted from House v. NCAA, said Boise State law professor Sam Ehrlich, who has been closely following House v. NCAA. (He added that this wasn’t uncommon for lawsuits similar in nature.)

“I’ll wonder if [Hill v. NCAA is] shooting for a better settlement or actual litigation on the merits,” he tells FOS. “The latter would be especially interesting because I think the NCAA is very keen on not having liability on this sort of claim.” 

Plaintiff attorneys for Hill v. NCAA did not respond to an emailed request for comment.

While these lawsuits continue, the House v. NCAA settlement proposal will be discussed in a final approval hearing on April 7. But rather than the end of the story on the evolution of amateurism, the House case seems to be just the beginning.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

The Next Chapter in the Network Battle for College Football Dominance

Saturday’s Texas–Ohio State matchup is the next chapter.
exclusive

Ryen Russillo Leaving Ringer, Dave Portnoy Expected to Invest in New Business

Russillo has one of the world’s most popular sports podcasts.

Fox, YouTube TV Avoid Blackout With Short-Term Deal

The upcoming Texas–Ohio State clash will remain available to subscribers.
Mat Ishbia

Suns, Mat Ishbia Sued By Minority Owners Looking to Open Books

The limited partners have been seeking a buyout from Ishbia.

Featured Today

‘You’re Going to Get Beat Up’: The Liberty’s All-Male Practice Squad

A select group suits up weekly to take on the defending champs.
August 24, 2025

The Honey Deuce Effect: How Tennis Perfected the Signature Cocktail

Sold every 1.5 seconds, they total more than $12 million in sales.
Dec 21, 2024; Austin, Texas, USA; Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning (16) warms up as the Texas Longhorns prepare to play the Clemson Tigers in the first round of the College Football Playoffs at Darrell K Royal Texas Memorial Stadium.
August 23, 2025

Schools Are Hesitant to Allow PE Into Their Athletic Departments

Regardless of budget, schools don’t believe the risk is worth the reward.
Oct 2, 2024; Rosemont, IL, USA; Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti speaks with the media during the 2024 Big Ten Women’s Basketball media day at Donald E. Stephens Convention Center.
August 22, 2025

‘Not Ready to Jump In’: Power 4 Commissioners Aren’t Sold on PE

Top leaders in college sports have yet to see a satisfactory proposal.
Oct 17, 2015; Evanston, IL, USA; A general view of the Northwestern Wildcats logo at midfield before the game against the Iowa Hawkeyes at Ryan Field.
August 25, 2025

Northwestern AD Singles Out Volleyball As Sport to Invest In

Northwestern athletic director Mark Jackson spoke to Front Office Sports.
Oregon State Beavers quarterback Gevani McCoy (4) scrambles out of the pocket during an NCAA football game against UNLV at Reser Stadium on Saturday, Oct. 19, 2024, in Corvallis, Ore.
August 27, 2025

Pac-12 Strikes New Football, Basketball Deal With The CW

The latest step in its resurrection after being picked apart in 2023.
Sponsored

Gareth Bale on MLS vs EPL, Retirement & Buying Cardiff City

Gareth Bale shares his post-soccer business playbook.
Dec 21, 2024; Austin, Texas, USA; Texas Longhorns quarterback Arch Manning (16) is tackled by Clemson Tigers defensive tackle Payton Page (55) during the second half of the CFP National playoff first round at Darrell K Royal-Texas Memorial Stadium
August 25, 2025

As College Football Season Kicks Off, NIL Deal Approval Process Still Lags

Many deals are stuck in “purgatory,” one power conference collective operator says.
August 25, 2025

$12.5M Freshman Bryce Underwood Named Michigan’s Starting QB

The Wolverines paid big money to land the highly touted recruit.
McDonald's All-American
August 22, 2025

NCAA Considers Making High School Athletes Register NIL Deals

The rule would likely be tested in court if adopted.
Nov 23, 2024; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Penn State Nittany Lions head coach James Franklin looks at quarterback Drew Allar (15) during the first quarter against the Minnesota Golden Gophers at Huntington Bank Stadium.
August 22, 2025

Private Equity Enters College Sports—Without the Equity

As college football starts, lending agreements have become PE’s best way in.