• Loading stock data...
Tuesday, January 21, 2025

One Year of NIL: Controversial Collectives Aren’t Going Away

  • NIL collectives have dominated media headlines in the first year of the NIL era.
  • Right now, they may be less impactful than expected — but experts think their future is bright.
Daniel Dunn-USA TODAY Sports

Over the past several months, collectives have been framed as the scandalous side of NIL. 

There have been reports of million-dollar deals being used as recruiting inducements and rumors of bidding wars. They’ve drawn the ire of Nick Saban and countless other college sports officials, who think they could ruin the future of college sports by facilitating pay for play.

But athletes and industry experts told Front Office Sports that currently, collectives are much less powerful than the headlines would suggest. And instead of “ruining” college sports, collectives could be an efficient and lucrative resource for athletes — and hardly a dark underbelly of college sports.

The Current Landscape

Generally, NIL collectives are groups of donors, alumni, boosters, and local businesses who pool resources to provide NIL opportunities for athletes at a certain school. Some are providing deals using their own businesses, while others are acting as agencies, facilitating opportunities for athletes.

There are more than 60 active collectives, according to Business of College Sports. A few, like Oregon’s Division Street or Tennessee’s Spyre Sports collective, are well-funded and active. The ones offering six, seven, or even eight-figure deals are also in the vast minority. 

But, Opendorse CEO Blake Lawrence told FOS that according to his data, the media coverage around collectives has made their impact seem larger than it is. “There’s a big gap between the collectives that have figured it out…and those that are creating a lot of buzz through announcements, but aren’t doing much in reality.”

Positive Cases

Front Office Sports spoke with athletes who all believe collectives are currently benefiting athletes — and can continue to do so in the future.

Over this first year of the name, image, and likeness era, NC State offensive lineman Tim McCay has done all of his deals through an NIL collective called the “Pack of Wolves.” He was the first athlete to sign with the group, and he says his experience so far has been positive. 

“They’ve really helped me connect with donors and alumni,” he told Front Office Sports at the first-ever NIL Summit in Atlanta earlier this month. McCay is now an ambassador for the group and is helping with some NFT development.

NIL trailblazer and former Rutgers guard Geo Baker thinks his alma mater’s collective is working well. The Knights of Raritan is focused on procuring deals for current athletes, he said, rather than trying to get into the recruiting landscape.

But he noted that at other schools, the deals that could be considered recruiting inducements are just deals that probably would’ve been under the table anyway. 

The Future Factors

Experts agree that collectives aren’t going away. In the next few years, the big questions are how much they’ll influence recruiting, and how much they’ll actually benefit athletes.

With updated guidance in May, the NCAA itself tried to push collectives out of recruiting altogether: 

  • The policy said that boosters were not allowed to communicate with potential recruits at all — including about NIL deals. Coaches aren’t allowed to promise deals, either. 
  • At some point, multiple legal experts predict that the NCAA will attempt to punish a collective — potentially further clarifying the rules for the rest.

But the NCAA hasn’t been successful so far at kicking collectives out of recruiting. And even if the rules get stricter, collectives can still have an above-board influence. 

How? Kennyhertz Perry attorney Mit Winter predicted that in coming years, collectives will develop reputations — and won’t have to talk to recruits at all. Coaches “can say, yeah, look over here at this, we have this collective, and here are some historical deals that they have done with guys on our team, and here are the range of those deals.”

The success of collectives for athletes could also depend on who is running the collective. Are they following the rules? Are they offering fair contracts?

Mike Hamilton, executive vice president of the university partnership group at Learfield — and former Tennessee athletic director — added another major piece to the collective puzzle: “How will the return on investment be defined?”

If a donor offers a major deal to an athlete who doesn’t end up playing well, will that donor think twice about doing an NIL deal in the future? Hamilton believes that over time, the market will “self-correct.”

The crux of the collective issue is that it’s created an above-board way for boosters to pay athletes — something the NCAA has always considered taboo. But finally, schools will have to grapple with an issue they can no longer prevent.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Grant House and about 50 former and current athletes met at the College Football Playoff to discuss organizing efforts.

Players at the CFP Championship Are Talking About Unionizing

“It’s really just about our voices being heard,” one player said.

Unrivaled’s Impeccable Timing Pressures WNBA to Give Players More

The league could “blow the lid off” the business of women’s sports.

Wisconsin Accuses Miami of Tampering in Xavier Lucas Transfer

Cornerback Xavier Lucas announced his departure without going through the transfer portal.
Notre Dame Fighting Irish quarterback Riley Leonard (13) celebrates with fans after winning a game between the Indiana Hoosiers and the Notre Dame Fighting Irish in first round of the College Football Playoff on Saturday, Dec. 21, 2024, in South Bend. Notre Dame defeated Indiana 27-17.

CFP Executive Director: More On-Campus Games Are a Possibility

FBS commissioners will discuss more CFP games o campus in the future.

Featured Today

Notre Dame Fighting Irish quarterback Riley Leonard and running back Jeremiah Love celebrate a touchdown during the first half of a game against the Indiana Hoosiers in the first round of the College Football Playoff.

Notre Dame Found a Title-Worthy NIL Formula. Now It Has to Pivot

Its title run was buoyed by a collective that no longer exists.
Jan 17, 2025; Miami, FL, USA; Dearica Hamby (5) of the Vinyl reaches for the ball as Azura Stevens (23) of the Rose follows on the play during the second half of the Unrivaled women’s professional 3v3 basketball league at Wayfair Arena.
January 17, 2025

Inside Unrivaled’s Explosive Opening Night

The 3-on-3 league went big for its season opener in Miami.
Baseball for All founder Justine Siegal walks in front of the over 400 young players participating in her league during the opening ceremony for an organization focused on giving girls an opportunity to play baseball, at Hohokam Stadium in Mesa, Ariz. on Wednesday, July 20, 2022. Baseball For All 15 Mar 30, 2023; Miami, Florida, USA; Miami Marlins general manager Kim Ng walks on the field prior to the game against the New York Mets at loanDepot Park.
January 17, 2025

Can a Professional Women’s Baseball League Launch in Softball’s Shadow?

The biggest hurdle to the WPBL’s success may be its closest kindred.
Showboats’ Daewood Davis (2) celebrates after scoring a touchdown during the UFL game between the San Antonio Brahmas and Memphis Showboats in Simmons Liberty Bank Stadium in Simmons Bank Liberty Stadium in Memphis, Tenn., on Saturday, April 6, 2024.
January 15, 2025

The UFL Is Primed for Success—If It Can Resist Its Impulse for..

The spring football league must buck temptation if it wants to succeed.

Ohio State’s $20M NIL Roster Just Won the National Championship

It’s believed to be one of the highest payrolls in CFB.
January 19, 2025

What’s Next for the CFP? Expansion, Format Changes on the Horizon

Year 1 of the expanded College Football Playoff concludes Monday.
January 19, 2025

CFP Title Game and Inauguration Falling on Same Day for First Time

The CFP executive director called it a “big day for the country.”
Sponsored

How UBS Crafts Impactful Partnerships Across Sports, Arts, and Culture

As UBS continues to expand its impressive array of sports and entertainment partnerships, the company solidifies its position as a leader in wealth management.
January 19, 2025

CFP Finale: Ohio State’s Redemption vs. Notre Dame’s Independence

Ohio State and Notre Dame face off in Atlanta on Monday night.
Nebraska's Rebekah Allick, right, lunges to pass the ball during a Big Ten volleyball match against Penn State at Rec Hall on Friday, Nov. 29, 2024, in State College, Pa.
January 17, 2025

DOE Issues More Guidance on Title IX Application to Athlete Pay

Financial assistance, including revenue-sharing, has to be equitable.
*** THIS IS THE FULL CROP of Fred Squillante's famous 1995 photo of Eddie George vs. Notre Dame. *** (Scanned in 10/97 for use in calendar of OSU's great football moments.) *** KEEP IN THE ARCHIVE ALONG WITH THE TIGHTER-CROPPED ONE! *** Eddie George gets away from the Notre Dame defense on a long run. OSU Buckeyes vs. Notre Dame Fighting Irish . Ohio State University college football . Game played on Sat., September 30, 1995 .
January 17, 2025

Biden’s Justice Department Asks Judge to Deny House v. NCAA Settlement

The agency filed a scathing, 11-page request Friday.
Jan 15, 2025; Long Beach, California, USA; UCLA Bruins forward Kendall Dudley (22), forward Timea Gardiner (30), guard Avary Cain (2) and forward Zania Socka-Nguemen (6) react in the second half against the Penn State Nittany Lions at the Walter Pyramid at Long Beach State.
January 16, 2025

Education Dept. Says Title IX Applies to College Athlete Revenue-Sharing

Title IX protects students from sex-based discrimination in schools.