• Loading stock data...
Tuesday, April 29, 2025
Law

Carmelo Anthony Testimony Appears to Backfire in NASL-U.S. Soccer Trial

Anthony’s testimony led the judge to consider altering jury instructions in the $500 million antitrust trial.

Carmelo Anthony
Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images

NBA legend Carmelo Anthony tried a different type of court yesterday, and it didn’t go as well as his Hall of Fame career on the hardwood. Anthony, a former North American Soccer League owner, testified Wednesday in the defunct league’s antitrust trial against the U.S. Soccer Federation (USSF) and Major League Soccer in its second week in Brooklyn federal court.

The judge in the case, Hector Gonzalez, criticized Anthony’s appearance after he and the jury departed. Gonzalez said he did not understand why Anthony testified, as the lawsuit was brought by the league and not the owners. And in a sign that the testimony may have backfired, the judge said he may narrow the jury instructions.

“After listening to that testimony I am thinking of changing the damages instruction,” said Judge Hector Gonzalez. Currently the instructions say only damages—if jurors vote in favor of NASL—are tied to antitrust violations. Gonzalez said he was considering adding a clause to the damages instruction that any monetary amount not reflect losses by individual owners.

That may be due to the sad story Anthony told Wednesday, plus his status as a celebrity.

Anthony owned Puerto Rico FC from 2015 until the league shuttered in late 2017. That’s when U.S. Soccer declined to renew its Division II status, a decision NASL alleges was a result of a conspiracy between U.S. Soccer and MLS. That alleged conspiracy is the heart of the antitrust trial that finally kicked off last week after years of legal wrangling. NASL is suing for up to $170 million. The damages, if awarded, would be tripled under antitrust law to more than $500 million.

Anthony testified about bringing a pro soccer team to the island, and the devastating effect of Hurricane Maria in 2017. The team’s players and staff were left homeless, and its venue destroyed, he testified.

He was subjected to a tough cross examination by MLS outside counsel, Keisha-Ann G. Gray of Proskauer Rose. Anthony said he had never seen the league’s financials, did not know his own club’s financial state, and was unaware of the danger of NASL investor Traffic Sports’ role in the 2015 FIFA bribery scandal.  

The defense has argued NASL failed due to bad business plans and poor choices—not an alleged conspiracy between USSF and MLS. That dispute was at the heart of Anthony’s cross-examination Wednesday.

Gray, the lawyer for MLS, showed Anthony an email from a fellow owner warning that the bribery scandal threatened the league’s future, and another who wrote he was worried Traffic was using NASL to launder money. Anthony was included on each email, though he testified he was unaware of their content until the lawyer read them.

Anthony, who owns a Brooklyn-based media company, repeatedly said he relied in 2015 on his “team” to perform due diligence, meaning his lawyer and others. “My team was responsible for this, I was doing what I had to do with my other job,” Anthony testified, referring to his spot on the New York Knicks at the time. Anthony did not pay a fee to acquire the team.

Gray also pressed Anthony on why exactly Puerto Rico FC failed. In a years-old deposition, he had pinned the club’s collapse on Hurricane Maria. Now, in court, he was blaming the later denial of NASL’s Division II sanction. Asked which it was after Gray read the deposition back to him, Anthony replied: “It was a double whammy.”

At the end of her cross-examination, Gray waved Anthony’s autobiography and noted it says he achieved his success through hard work, sacrifice, and commitment.  Looking toward the table where the NASL team was seated, she said that’s true in general, a subtle swipe at the defunct league. 

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

exclusive

WME Looks to Sell Off Baseball Agency Due to Union Pressure

The situation arises as Endeavor is once again a private company.
exclusive

Dwyane Wade, Candace Parker Expected to Join Amazon NBA Coverage

Parker would be a studio analyst for both NBA and WNBA games.
May 24, 2024; Eugene, Oregon, USA; A Nike swoosh logo at Nike

Nike Apologizes and Removes ‘Never Again’ Marathon Ad

The billboard drew criticism for wording often linked to the Holocaust.

Featured Today

How DJ Adam Amin Mixes Baseball With Bangers

Amin is one of Fox’s top NFL and MLB voices.
Jun 21, 2024; Boston, MA, USA; Boston Celtics majority owner Wyc Grousbeck holds the Larry O’Brien trophy prior to the Boston Celtics championship parade.
April 27, 2025

The Celtics Succession Plan Remains Murky

The transfer of power to a private-equity group is still unresolved.
April 26, 2025

The Rays Groundskeepers Are Adjusting to Life Outside the Dome

After nearly three decades in a dome, Tampa groundskeepers were forced outside.
April 25, 2025

The Former NBA Agent Who Became a Pickleball Deputy Commissioner

Chris Patrick went from representing Jimmy Butler to pickleball deputy commissioner.

Fox Sports Fires FS1 Exec Charlie Dixon

Dixon was named in two separate lawsuits in January.
Nike
April 28, 2025

Nike Accused of ‘Misleading’ NFT Scheme In Lawsuit

Nike pulled the rug out from under investors, the complaint says.
Feb 16, 2013; Lawrence, KS, USA; Former Kansas Jayhawks guard Mario Chalmers talks to the crowd as his jersey is retired during halftime of the game against the Texas Longhorns at Allen Fieldhouse.
April 28, 2025

In Major Win for NCAA, Judge Dismisses Lawsuit Seeking NIL Damages

It’s a major win for the NCAA, which faces a group of similar lawsuits.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Portfolio Players is our bi-weekly spotlight on the athletes and investors reshaping the business of sports. This week, venture capitalist Kai Cunningham unpacks why athletes land top deals and how the usual investing rules don’t always apply.
Jan 15, 2024; Boston, Massachusetts, USA; New Jersey Devils center Michael McLeod (20) tries to hold off Boston Bruins center Jakub Lauko (94) during the second period at TD Garden.
April 25, 2025

Mistrial Declared for Five Ex-NHL Canadians Accused of Sexual Assault

The trial started Tuesday over an alleged 2018 incident in a hotel room.
Jan 20, 2024; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Philadelphia Flyers goalie Carter Hart (79) reacts after allowing a goal against the Colorado Avalanche in the first period at Wells Fargo Center
April 22, 2025

Trial Begins for Five Ex-NHL Canadians Accused of Sexual Assault

The players were on Canada’s junior national team during the alleged incident.
Kendrick Lamar
April 18, 2025

Drake Lawsuit Says Kendrick Lamar Defamed Him At Super Bowl

Drake says taking out the word “pedophile” didn’t erase the defamation.
Reilly Opelka
April 12, 2025

Tennis Player Testifies ATP Threatened Him For Supporting Lawsuit

The tour denied the allegation in a Friday court hearing.