• Loading stock data...
Thursday, October 3, 2024
The Best Employers in Sports survey is now open! Take the survey

Opening Briefs in NCAA v. Alston Use Old Arguments

  • The NCAA and FBS conferences have submitted opening briefs for what could be a landmark Supreme Court case, NCAA v. Alston.
  • Briefs submitted by the NCAA and conferences for NCAA v. Alston show the NCAA will continue to espouse a decades-old legal argument.
Hannah Gaber-USA TODAY

The NCAA and FBS conferences have submitted opening briefs for what could be a landmark Supreme Court case, NCAA v. Alston, and its conjunction case, AAC v. Alston.

The arguments at the March 31 hearing will center around whether the NCAA violates antitrust law by limiting the “education-related” benefits for football or basketball players.

Based on the briefs, the NCAA will continue to espouse a decades-old legal argument. The Supreme Court will decide whether the argument still holds, and whether the NCAA must alter its entire business model.

The Big Deal About Antitrust

Whether the NCAA is violating antitrust law — and whether it can secure an exemption from Congress or the Supreme Court — could influence:

  • Whether the NCAA could use an antitrust exemption to prohibit group licensing and the portrayal of real athletes in EA’s new college football video game 
  • Whether it could prohibit athletes from being subject to employment law
  • Whether its business model can continue to rely upon not paying athletes

Old Argument is New Again

They continue to center their legal arguments around the “amateurism” argument, their briefs revealed.

The NCAA claims its product is popular with fans because athletes are amateurs — meaning they’re unpaid. By compensating athletes for playing, the argument goes, college sports lose their competitive luster in the sports market.

“The NCAA amateurism principle has governed college sports for generations, and has been recognized by courts as central to the enterprise throughout that time,” the Big Ten’s brief said. “It cannot be seriously contended that the eligibility rules were created to disguise an anticompetitive conspiracy.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

TNT Has Staked Its Claim in College Sports Broadcasting

The network has quietly amassed a portfolio of NCAA rights.

Conference Realignment Continues

The Pac-12 and Mountain West keep making moves.
Gonzaga Bulldogs forward Anton Watson

Pac-12, Mountain West Continue to Load Up With Gonzaga, UTEP Moves

The conferences, now rivals, have been at the center of the most recent wave.

UNLV Rebuffs Gambling Exec’s Offer To Pay Spurned QB $100K

UNLV lost its starting quarterback earlier this week in an NIL dispute.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Domantas Sabonis on Life Behind Scenes of NBA Stars

0:00

Featured Today

The Cal mascot, Oski

How the Calgorithm Turned College Football Twitter Into Real Life

“College GameDay” makes its first trip to Berkeley on Saturday.
Apr 8, 2022; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; The cleats of Philadelphia Phillies right fielder Bryce Harper (3) as he runs the bases against the Oakland Athletics during the seventh inning at Citizens Bank Park.
October 1, 2024

MLB Players Are Clamoring for Swag. Outfitting Them Is Big Business

Sliding mitts, cleats, and belts are fun, flashy, and lucrative.
Sep 25, 2024; Los Angeles, California, USA; San Diego Padres right fielder Fernando Tatis Jr. (23) celebrates after hitting a solo home run in the fifth inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium.
September 30, 2024

The Padres’ Future Is on the Line This Postseason

The MLB playoffs could determine the team’s path forward.
Aug 3, 2024; East Rutherford, NJ, USA; Barcelona midfielder Pau Victor (8) celebrates his goal with teammates during the second half of an international friendly against Real Madrid at MetLife Stadium. V
September 29, 2024

FC Barcelona’s Overspending Triggered a Crisis. Has It Tightened Its Belt Enough?

The club is betting on their middle-road strategy to dig out.
Sep 16, 2023; Stanford, California, USA; Sacramento State Hornets running back Elijah Tau-Tolliver (25) celebrates after a touchdown during the fourth quarter against the Stanford Cardinal at Stanford Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Sergio Estrada-USA TODAY Sports

Sacramento State Raised $35 Million in One Day for Its NIL Collective

The so-called Sac-12 announced it had raised $35 million in NIL for the university.
Running back Kalel Mullings (20) celebrates a touchdown against USC with teammates during the second half at Michigan Stadium in Ann Arbor on Saturday, Sept. 21, 2024.
September 26, 2024

House v. NCAA Lawyers Amend Settlement to Address Concerns About Boosters and NIL

Judge Claudia Wilken had concerns about the definition of the word “booster.”
September 27, 2024

Pac-12, Mountain West Eye Expansion As Realignment Enters Next Phase

The conferences have been fighting each other for members.
Sponsored

Trend Report: Chiefs-Chargers, Tobacco Road Rivalry, Nebraska Sellout Streak

According to data from TickPick, some games this week will prove to be wallet-busters, climbing into the four figures.
September 26, 2024

Mountain West Schools Have Signed a Retention Deal

The seven members of the Mountain West signed an agreement to stay with the conference.
September 26, 2024

College Football’s Chaotic Week: Realignment, Redshirts, and NIL

The shifting college landscape keeps leading to firsts across the sport.
UNLV QB Matt Sluka
September 26, 2024

Settlement in NCAA’s House Case Wouldn’t Prevent Future Matt Slukas

Situations like the UNLV mess may become even more common.
September 25, 2024

Woj Plans to Go From Dropping Bombs to Being a ‘Giant-Killer’

The former ESPN news-breaker calls the shift to his alma mater a natural next step.