• Loading stock data...
Thursday, March 28, 2024
2024 Best Venues nominations are open now through April 8! Submit Now

Time to Celebrate?

  • When the Supreme Court ruling on NCAA v. Alston came out, headlines proclaimed it the end of the amateurism.
  • The ruling invalidated one small part of the amateurism model -- but schools won't be cutting checks to players after practice.
supreme_court
Design: Alex Brooks

When the Supreme Court released its unanimous decision in NCAA v. Alston, the tweets and headlines came pouring in: Amateurism is dead! The NCAA’s business model is kaput! NCAA athletes will finally get their payday!

Not exactly. 

The ruling invalidated one small portion of the amateurism model, and paved a legal path to continue challenging the NCAA with future lawsuits.

It won’t result in schools cutting checks to players after practice. There’s still a long way to go.

“This historic 9-0 decision is about the athletes, especially those who will never join the pros,” lead counsel for the Alston camp, Jeffrey Kessler, told FOS in a statement. “Hopefully, it will also swing the doors open to further change…Only then will the NCAA truthfully be able to say it is devoted to the welfare of the student athletes.”

The Court’s Narrow View

NCAA v. Alston centered around a much less controversial issue than paying players: Whether limiting the education-related benefits for Division I football and basketball players violates antitrust. 

The Supreme Court found only that this one small part of amateurism was illegal. 

The opinion could, however, help amateurism challenges in the future. It established that the NCAA is subject to scrutiny. And it invalidated one of the NCAA’s decades-long legal defenses.

Both of these things give power and legitimacy to future challenges of amateurism.

Kavanaugh Attacks Entire NCAA

While the main opinion refused to address the rest of amateurism, Kavanaugh’s concurring opinion criticized the entire business model.

His concurrence was heralded as the end of amateurism. But it isn’t — it holds much less weight than the main opinion and is neither precedent nor law. But it does serve as an open invitation for athletes and advocates to bring more lawsuits. Step right up, Kavanaugh said. You have a friend in the high court. 

Of the many biting quotes, his opinion included this: “The NCAA’s business model would be flatly illegal in almost any other industry in America.” And this: “The NCAA’s remaining compensation rules also raise serious questions under the antitrust laws.” 

Not to mention this: “But the students who generate the revenues, many of whom are African American and from lower-income backgrounds, end up with little or nothing.”

And, of course: “The NCAA is not above the law.”

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

NCAA President Calls for Nationwide Ban on College Prop Bets

The NCAA president is reacting to the recent betting turmoil in sports.
Robert McRae III, Dartmouth men's basketball

Congress Is Finally Talking About College Athlete Employment Status

Federal lawmakers are focusing on the biggest question—and it’s not NIL.

Who Is the Highest-Paid Men’s College Basketball Coach?

Kansas’ Bill Self has been with the program for 20 years.

‘We Want to Be Paid’: Inside Dartmouth Men’s Basketball’s Historic Union Effort

A group of players made history when they became the first NCAA team to vote to unionize.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

MLB Opens Season With MLBPA, Ohtani, and Ownership Dramas

0:00
0:00

Featured Today

March 22, 2024, Brooklyn, NY, USA; Northwestern Wildcats guard Brooks Barnhizer (13) and Northwestern Wildcats guard Boo Buie (0) react in overtime against the Florida Atlantic Owls in the first round of the 2024 NCAA Tournament at the Barclays Center.

‘An Expensive Game’: March Madness and NIL Collectives Are Intertwined

At schools nationwide, collectives are fueling NCAA tournament runs and vice versa.
Iowa’s Caitlin Clark (22) waits to be announced in the starting lineup against West Virginia in a NCAA Tournament round of 32 game Monday, March 25, 2024 at Carver-Hawkeye Arena in Iowa City, Iowa.
March 26, 2024

The Women’s Trading Card Market Is Overlooked. Can Caitlin Clark Change That?

Traditionally, women’s sports cards have been a marginal part of collectibles.
The Sports Illustrated cover signed by Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez, February 27, 2019, at Don & Charlie's, 7501 E. Camelback Road, Scottsdale. Don Charlie S
March 24, 2024

Everything You Need to Know About the Ongoing ‘Sports Illustrated’ Saga

Understanding the strange state of affairs for the nearly 70-year-old publication.
March 23, 2024

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly: Inside the Big East’s Bizarre Online Subculture

Peeling back the curtain on the ‘phenomenally weird’ Big East online ecosystem.

Careers

Powered By

Careers in Sports

Looking for a new job? Check out these featured listings and search for openings all over the world.
Live Nation
Multiple - USA Careers
Adidas
Multiple - USA Careers
Spotify
Multiple - USA Careers

How Lack of Planning by NCAA, Gonzaga Led to Racial Abuse of Utah Athletes

The NCAA gave Gonzaga a waiver to place teams in an extremist hotbed.
March 25, 2024

The Brian Kelly ‘Hit Job’ Kim Mulkey Ripped Is Barely About Brian Kelly at All

The article was hardly about Kelly at all.
March 25, 2024

The Pac-12’s Departing Members Have Inked Their Divorce Contract

The settlement resolves a lawsuit brought last fall.
Sponsored

How Daily Fantasy Sports Solved NBA Fantasy

The remarkable growth of the #1 Discord sports server in the world.
March 22, 2024

March Madness Upsets Reflect Deeper Changes in College Landscape

Calipari laments the reduced role in the sport for younger players.
Mar 21, 2024; Brooklyn, NY, USA; Stetson Hatters guard Stephan Swenson (30) reacts during team practice at Barclays Center.
March 22, 2024

First-Time NCAA Men’s Tourney Bids Could Be on the Verge of Extinction

Power and success are consolidating around the richest teams in college sports.
March 21, 2024

Is Bigger Better? Coaches Divided on March Madness Expansion

Expanding the men’s NCAA tournament has been a big talking point this week.
March 21, 2024

Ready for Liftoff: Women’s Hoops Set to Break March Madness Viewership Marks

The women’s NCAA tournament tips off Friday afternoon.