• Loading stock data...
Saturday, July 19, 2025
Law

Carmelo Anthony Testimony Appears to Backfire in NASL-U.S. Soccer Trial

Anthony’s testimony led the judge to consider altering jury instructions in the $500 million antitrust trial.

Carmelo Anthony
Wendell Cruz-Imagn Images

NBA legend Carmelo Anthony tried a different type of court yesterday, and it didn’t go as well as his Hall of Fame career on the hardwood. Anthony, a former North American Soccer League owner, testified Wednesday in the defunct league’s antitrust trial against the U.S. Soccer Federation (USSF) and Major League Soccer in its second week in Brooklyn federal court.

The judge in the case, Hector Gonzalez, criticized Anthony’s appearance after he and the jury departed. Gonzalez said he did not understand why Anthony testified, as the lawsuit was brought by the league and not the owners. And in a sign that the testimony may have backfired, the judge said he may narrow the jury instructions.

“After listening to that testimony I am thinking of changing the damages instruction,” said Judge Hector Gonzalez. Currently the instructions say only damages—if jurors vote in favor of NASL—are tied to antitrust violations. Gonzalez said he was considering adding a clause to the damages instruction that any monetary amount not reflect losses by individual owners.

That may be due to the sad story Anthony told Wednesday, plus his status as a celebrity.

Anthony owned Puerto Rico FC from 2015 until the league shuttered in late 2017. That’s when U.S. Soccer declined to renew its Division II status, a decision NASL alleges was a result of a conspiracy between U.S. Soccer and MLS. That alleged conspiracy is the heart of the antitrust trial that finally kicked off last week after years of legal wrangling. NASL is suing for up to $170 million. The damages, if awarded, would be tripled under antitrust law to more than $500 million.

Anthony testified about bringing a pro soccer team to the island, and the devastating effect of Hurricane Maria in 2017. The team’s players and staff were left homeless, and its venue destroyed, he testified.

He was subjected to a tough cross examination by MLS outside counsel, Keisha-Ann G. Gray of Proskauer Rose. Anthony said he had never seen the league’s financials, did not know his own club’s financial state, and was unaware of the danger of NASL investor Traffic Sports’ role in the 2015 FIFA bribery scandal.  

The defense has argued NASL failed due to bad business plans and poor choices—not an alleged conspiracy between USSF and MLS. That dispute was at the heart of Anthony’s cross-examination Wednesday.

Gray, the lawyer for MLS, showed Anthony an email from a fellow owner warning that the bribery scandal threatened the league’s future, and another who wrote he was worried Traffic was using NASL to launder money. Anthony was included on each email, though he testified he was unaware of their content until the lawyer read them.

Anthony, who owns a Brooklyn-based media company, repeatedly said he relied in 2015 on his “team” to perform due diligence, meaning his lawyer and others. “My team was responsible for this, I was doing what I had to do with my other job,” Anthony testified, referring to his spot on the New York Knicks at the time. Anthony did not pay a fee to acquire the team.

Gray also pressed Anthony on why exactly Puerto Rico FC failed. In a years-old deposition, he had pinned the club’s collapse on Hurricane Maria. Now, in court, he was blaming the later denial of NASL’s Division II sanction. Asked which it was after Gray read the deposition back to him, Anthony replied: “It was a double whammy.”

At the end of her cross-examination, Gray waved Anthony’s autobiography and noted it says he achieved his success through hard work, sacrifice, and commitment.  Looking toward the table where the NASL team was seated, she said that’s true in general, a subtle swipe at the defunct league. 

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Jul 13, 2025; Atlanta, GA, USA; MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred announces the pick for the Athletics pick during the MLB Draft at The Coca-Cola Roxy.

Manfred Says MLB Had Wrong Approach to Creators Like Jomboy

“You gotta go where people are going,” the commissioner said.
(NCL_OSU_11_SUGAR_LAURON 04JAN11) Ohio State Buckeyes quarterback Terrelle Pryor (2) slips around the Arkansas Razorbacks defense during first half of the Sugar Bowl at the Louisiana Superdome in New Orleans, January 4, 2011.

Terrelle Pryor’s Case for NIL Backpay Dismissed in Court

Pryor played seven years in the NFL after leaving OSU amid a scandal.
Jun 9, 2025; Cleveland, Ohio, USA; Cleveland Guardians starting pitcher Luis Ortiz (45) reacts after giving up a home run during the fourth inning against the Cincinnati Reds at Progressive Field.

MLB Pitcher’s Paid Leave Extended Through August As Betting Probe Continues

Leagues have been dealing with a host of sports betting issues.

Featured Today

Jul 21, 2024; Ayrshire, SCT; Xander Schauffele celebrates with Claret Jug after winning the Open Championship golf tournament at Royal Troon.

The Boozy History and Traditions of The Open’s Claret Jug

The Open awards the world’s most famous wine decanter.
2025 PDC World Darts Championship Final - Luke Littler vs Michael Van Gerwen
July 16, 2025

A Teen Darts Prodigy Is Becoming Bigger Than the Game Itself

Luke ‘The Nuke’ Littler is cashing in on his devastatingly accurate shot.
May 31, 2025; Philadelphia, PA, USA; Sydney McLaughin-Levrone (USA) reacts before the women's 100m hurdles during the Grand Slam Track Philadelphia at Franklin Field
exclusive
July 13, 2025

Track’s New Money Is Running Into Old Problems

The sport’s big-money era has hit some speed bumps in 2025.
Bobbleheads are seen at Vintage Indy Sports, Tuesday, April 29, 2025 in Speedway. The local sports memorabilia store opened recently.
July 12, 2025

Baseball’s Bobbleheads Are the Center of the Collectibles Universe

Baseball’s most important keepsake drives long lines—and big business.
Princeton

Transgender Sprinter Sues Princeton Over Last-Minute Ban

The sprinter was removed 15 minutes before her race.
Caster Semenya
July 10, 2025

Caster Semenya’s Legal Win Could Reopen Fight Against Testosterone Limits

The Olympian champion’s appeal against gender eligibility rules continues.
July 16, 2025

Judge Rules for NFL, Fanatics Against Small Apparel Seller

The lawsuit argued the NFL “aids and abets” Fanatics with its strategy.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
A set of trading cards
July 9, 2025

Judge Rules Against Fanatics as Panini Case Gets Rancorous

A judge ordered Fanatics to turn over unredacted trading card licenses.
May 9, 2024; Columbus, OH, USA; Sports are shown on TVs behind the bar as guests enjoy the grand opening of DraftKings Sports & Social in the Short North. Though there are no on-site betting windows, eligible customers can place bets through the DraftKings app.
July 3, 2025

PrizePicks Drops Suit Against Ex-Employee Who Left for DraftKings

The ex-employee still disputes the allegations.
Wander Franco
June 26, 2025

Wander Franco Convicted of Child Sex Abuse, Receives 2-Year Suspended Sentence

Franco can avoid jail time but is unlikely to return to MLB.
Wimbledon
June 25, 2025

Players Suing Tennis Begin Negotiations With Grand Slams

They may add the Slams as defendants if talks fail in 90 days.