• Loading stock data...
Friday, July 11, 2025

‘It Could Not Have Gone Better’ For the Athletes: First Session of NCAA Athlete Employment Trial Concludes

  • For three days in L.A. labor court, the NLRB has considered whether USC football and basketball players should be reclassified as employees.
  • The business model of amateurism is at stake and, so far, the athlete advocacy side is pleased.
USC
Jonathan Hui-USA TODAY Sports

The first session of a potentially earth-moving trial tied to college athlete employment status concluded on Wednesday in a labor court in Los Angeles.

The case was first filed with the National Labor Relations Board in 2022. The charging party, the National College Players Association, alleged that USC, the Pac-12, and the NCAA have misclassified USC football and basketball players as amateurs, rather than employees. 

If the NCPA prevails, it will not kill college sports. But it will kill the NCAA’s business model.

The NCAA's model of amateurism is on trial this week in labor court.

The NCAA’s Amateurism Model Is on Trial: Everything You Need To Know

A labor court in L.A. could reclassify some D-I athletes as employees.
December 18, 2023

After only three days of testimony, the NLRB, who is prosecuting the case on behalf of the NCPA, hasn’t yet rested its case, and the trial will resume in January. But so far, the athlete advocacy side is pleased. 

“It could not have gone better,” NCPA executive director Ramogi Huma said of his case.

Here’s everything you need to know: 

Inside the Courtroom

In a glorified conference room, there were a few rows of movable chairs behind desks for counsel, as well as an area for the judge and a court reporter to sit.

Just a handful of observers trickled in and out throughout the proceedings, and only a few  journalists attended throughout the three days. Most attendees were working the case: two lawyers for the NLRB, and at least nine brought by USC, the Pac-12, and the NCAA, including both in-house and outside counsel.  

Huma pointed out that the trial drew much less attendance than the 2014 Northwestern football player unionization case—even though this case could be just as impactful.

The Main Arguments

The NLRB’s lawyers opened by asserting that “an individual may be both a student and an employee of a university.” They also attacked the decades-old phrase of “student-athlete,” saying it “was created and has been perpetuated to deprive [college athletes] of workplace protections.”

Testimony and questioning focused on four main areas:

  • How much control USC, the Pac-12, and the NCAA exert over athletes
  • Whether athletes receive compensation from these entities
  • Whether college football and basketball are “extracurricular” 
  • Whether the voluntary nature of college sports means that activities aren’t employment

Former USC football walk-ons Miles “Kohl” Hollinquest and Brandon Outlaw testified that the school controlled much of their lives, from 60-hour schedules to weekly weigh-ins and hydration tests. This, the prosecutors suggested, contradicts the idea that big-time college football was merely “extracurricular.”

USC's lawyer referred to USC football and basketball as extracurricular activities.

USC’s Lawyer Calls Football and Basketball ‘Extracurricular Activities’

The NCAA’s amateurism model is on trial in L.A. labor court.
December 19, 2023

“If [USC strength] coach [Bennie] Wylie hands a kid a sandwich and says ‘eat this,’ I don’t think there’s a single guy that wouldn’t,” Outlaw said. If athletes didn’t follow these rules, they were subject to various forms of group punishment. 

Testimony from Hollinquest demonstrated compensation limits imposed on athletes by the school and NCAA. He received other acceptable perks, like a gift from the Pac-12 and gear and meal stipends from USC. But he was prohibited from profiting off of his own name, image, and likeness, given that he played before July 2021, when NIL rules were changed.

And while lawyers representing USC, the Pac-12, and the NCAA attempted in cross-examination to get the athletes to concede that playing college football is voluntary—to suggest that it isn’t employment—Outlaw specifically testified that he believes his current job at the XFL is also voluntary, but it’s still a job.

Cross-Examination

Ultimately, lawyers for USC, the Pac-12 and the NCAA all argued that college athletes are not employees. They attempted to establish that playing on a college football team was an educational experience that was more akin to playing high school and youth football—from practice schedules to free gear—than it was to employment. They also tried to show that the athletes in attendance joined their teams or enrolled at USC with the expectation of compensation.

But at times, lawyers for the NCAA, Pac-12, and USC appeared to contradict each other.

Even though USC’s lawyer called college football an “extracurricular activity” during opening arguments, for example, the NCAA’s lawyer engaged in a seemingly opposing line of questioning. That lawyer asked Outlaw whether he participated in any extracurricular activities at USC. His response was no.

What’s Next?

The next session will begin on Jan. 22 and run until Feb. 2. It will start with the NLRB calling adversarial witnesses and then will turn to the pro-amateurism side of the case.

If needed, the trial could continue in the final week of February, and there likely won’t be a ruling for several months afterward. It’s safe to assume that there will be a lengthy appeals process if the USC side loses.

Linkedin
Whatsapp
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

Rimouski, QC - JUNE 1: Final Game of the 2025 Memorial Cup between the Medicine Hats Tigers and the London Knights on June 1, 2025, at the Colisée Financière Sun Life in Rimouski, Qc.

CHL Is Facing a ‘Pandora’s Box’ of Questions Amid NCAA Talent Departure

As players defect to college, the Canadian Hockey League won’t cede ground.
The Florida State Seminoles hosted the Florida Gators at Doak Campbell Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 30, 2024.

Athletic Departments Express Renewed Interest in PE in Wake of House Settlement

Schools now have more expenses—and are looking for creative solutions.
Caster Semenya

Caster Semenya’s Legal Win Could Reopen Fight Against Testosterone Limits

The Olympian champion’s appeal against gender eligibility rules continues.
Gareth Bale
exclusive

Gareth Bale Group Makes New Offer for Cardiff City 

Bale tells Front Office Sports his group has made another bid.

Featured Today

Jun 28, 2025; Arlington, Texas, USA; Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (29) bats during the game between the Texas Rangers and the Seattle Mariners at Globe Life Field.

The Torpedo Bat Business Is Still Going Strong: ‘Here to Stay’

Demand for the oddly shaped bats has stayed strong across the sport.
July 6, 2025

American Celebs Want to Be Sports Owners. Soccer Is Where They Start

As U.S. team prices climb, investors set their sights abroad.
July 5, 2025

Baseball’s Celebrity Row: Behind MLB’s First-Pitch Ritual

Often planned, sometimes spontaneous, the ritual throw is baseball’s celebrity row.
July 4, 2025

3,000 Hot Dogs, $20K in Prizes: Behind the Nathan’s Eating Contest

Nathan’s serves up thousands of hot dogs and $20,000 in prize money.

Deion Sanders Rips ‘Bulljunk’ in CFB, Calls for NFL-Style Salary Cap

Coach Prime is frustrated with the new revenue-sharing era.
Jul 9, 2025; Frisco, TX, USA; Head coaches Willie Fritz of Houston, Mike Gundy of Oklahoma State, Rich Rodriguez of West Virginia, Lance Leipold of Kansas, Sonny Dykes of TCU, Kyle Whittingham of Utah, Brent Brennan of Arizona and Deion Sanders of Colorado all sit on stage for a Coaches Roundtable during 2025 Big 12 Football Media Days at The Star.
July 9, 2025

Big 12 Commish: Conference Is ‘All In’ on International Expansion

The conference had once planned a large initiative in Mexico.
Apr 4, 2025; Tampa, FL, USA; Connecticut Huskies guard KK Arnold (2)1 dribbles against UCLA Bruins forward Angela Dugalic (32) during the third quarter in a semifinal of the women's 2025 NCAA tournament at Amalie Arena.
July 10, 2025

‘Kind of a Joke’: Frustrations Mount As New NIL Deal Approval Process..

Delays have already led to athletes losing NIL opportunities.
Sponsored

Game On: Portfolio Players Stories, Brought to You by E*TRADE from Morgan Stanley

Dealmaker Jeffrey Kaplan maps the evolution of sports as an asset class
Sebastian Rivera (R) tf. Danny Coles 6:47 (20-3). Rutgers University Wrestling vs Princeton in Piscataway, NJ on February 18, 2022.
July 9, 2025

The House Settlement Is Being Appealed. It Won’t Stop Revenue-Sharing—for Now

The settlement’s approval on June 6 triggered an appeals process.
July 9, 2025

Big Ten, Big 12 Commissioners Remain Far Apart on CFP’s Future

A decision on expansion must be made by December.
TSU Hockey at Bridgestone
July 8, 2025

Tennessee State’s HBCU Hockey Ambitions Delayed at Least a Year

The school will not launch the first-of-its-kind program as intended.
Louis, Missouri, UNITED STATES; Penn State Nittany Lions forward Nicholas DeGraves (17) celebrates with teammates after scoring a goal against the Boston University Terriers during the third period of the Frozen Four college ice hockey national semifinals at Enterprise Center
July 7, 2025

Gavin McKenna’s Penn State Commitment Cements College Hockey Supremacy

Gavin McKenna’s Penn State decision signals hockey’s rising stars now prefer college.