November 12, 2021

Read in Browser

Front Office Sports

POWERED BY

In September, the Knight Commission released a new model that would alter the structure of NCAA and school finances — and presented it to the governing body. Ahead of Monday’s Constitutional Convention, it made one final push to make it part of the conversation.

– Amanda Christovich

Knight Commission’s Financial Action Plan

Photo: John Reed-USA TODAY/Design: Alex Brooks

A few days before the NCAA Constitutional Convention, a reform group called the Knight Commission is making one more push for “systemic change” in the NCAA.

It has a track record of making forceful recommendations the NCAA doesn’t ignore: Most recently, the NCAA has announced it’s considering eliminating standardized testing from eligibility and designating a Senior Minority Administrator.

In a press conference yesterday, it pushed its plan for a financial structure that would change the landscape of NCAA allocation: the C.A.R.E. model.

  • The C.A.R.E. model would change how the NCAA and Division I schools use the billions they generate — prioritizing education over ones “associated with seeking competitive advantages,” the report said.
  • It suggests freeing up current funds by creating conference-wide caps on spending for a particular sport or a “luxury tax” on coaching salaries, and redirecting them to improving the athlete experience.
  • Though the College Football Playoff operates separately from the NCAA, the Commission called on it to adopt the C.A.R.E. model, too — and even suggested it halt expansion talks until it commits.

This is hardly the only recommendation the Commission wants NCAA members to discuss, however. It also suggested adding more “independent” members to NCAA governing committees and giving athletes more voting power. 

And last December, it even said that FBS football should break away from the NCAA entirely — though it gave less weight to this radical idea at yesterday’s presser.

The common theme among all of its suggestions? Enhancing athlete-specific goals like education and gender equity.

SPONSORED BY OPENDORSE

NIL Market Explodes in Month 3

College athletes have received hundreds of thousands of NIL deals in the months since July 1 – and through its third month, the market appears to be hitting its stride. From August to September, Opendorse experienced a massive jump in spending and active athletes:

  • 4x increase in college athletes who received or disclosed a deal.
  • 2x increase in dollars spent by brands and fans on NIL transactions.

Opendorse analyzed tens of thousands of deals and activity disclosures, providing insight into the billion-dollar market to come. Click the link to find:

  • The conferences leading the way in athlete NIL compensation.
  • Which sports deliver the most dollars and deals.
  • What types of NIL deals are most common.
  • How men’s and women’s sports compare, and how DI, DII and DIII athletes stack up.

Opportunity for Change?

Photo: Kirby Lee-USA TODAY/ Design: Alex Brooks

The Knight Commission sees an opportunity to implement the C.A.R.E. model based on language in the NCAA constitution draft and outside support.

The Commission noted the draft includes the same principles as the C.A.R.E. model. But “the problem has been that the principles have not been fully put into practice,” CEO Amy Perko told reporters.

More importantly, if adopted, the draft also gives Division I the actual power to reorganize its budget — so the idea comes just in time. 

On top of that, the model has momentum.

  • Twenty-one Olympic sports coaches’ associations — part of the Intercollegiate Coaches Association Coalition — have endorsed the model. 
  • The NCAA’s Gender Equity Review pointed out that the current Division I revenue distribution model doesn’t support gender equity — a belief the C.A.R.E. model echoes.
  • “The C.A.R.E. model addresses the concerns we repeatedly hear from Congress, state lawmakers, and from the public,” former U.S. Secretary of Education and Knight Commission co-chair Arne Duncan said.

One potential caveat? Similar measures have been struck down by courts — such as the NCAA’s attempt decades ago to put a ceiling on coaching salaries.

Ultimately, it’s up to the membership to see whether the idea — or anything like it — makes it into the final copy. At Monday’s Constitutional Convention, the discussion continues.

In Other News

  • The Knight Commission isn’t the only reform movement with thoughts on the NCAA convention — the NCPA released a statement lambasting the Constitution draft. Read it here.
  • At meetings last week, the CFP considered a 12-team model that would guarantee six total spots: one spot for each Power 5 conference, and additionally one spot for the top-ranked Group of 5 conference champion, according to SI.
  • Law firm Morgan and Morgan continues to sign athletes nationwide to NIL deals. Its most recent deal is with Alabama offensive tackle Evan Neal.

SPONSORED BY STIHL TIMBERSPORTS®

U.S. STIHL TIMBERSPORTS® Championships On CBS

STIHL TIMBERSPORTS® made its epic return this year, thrilling millions of fans nationwide. Recognized as The Original Extreme Sport, it’s unlike anything you’ve ever seen. The best U.S. lumberjack sports athletes go head-to-head using razor sharp axes and high-powered chainsaws in a series of six disciplines.

This year, athletes brought more intensity than before, competing for the ultimate prize — the Championship title. New disciplines were added, eight records were broken, and three champions were crowned.

Catch the exciting, hour-long special on the 2021 U.S. Championships this Saturday, November 13th at 2 p.m. ET on CBS.

Final Thoughts

The Knight Commission said the NCAA is in need of an “overhaul” — hardly a radical opinion these days. 

But while many think the NCAA is simply beyond saving, the Commission still believes in the general system. 

It’s focused on reform models that would bring out the NCAA’s alleged “values” — prioritizing the athlete experience over wins and losses.

“How are the growing revenues being spent, and why aren’t more revenues spent to benefit the athletes themselves?” Duncan said.

Tips? Comments? Reach out to Amanda Christovich at amanda@fos.company or on Twitter.

Advertise Awards Learning Events Video Shows
Written by Amanda Christovich

If this email was forwarded to you, you can subscribe here.

Update your preferences / Unsubscribe

Copyright © 2021 Front Office Sports. All rights reserved.
460 Park Avenue South, 7th Floor, New York NY, 10016